Does one need a Euro-speced oil?

but its in my signature, what do you mean?
Sorry, did not see on the phone.
Not sure what is going on with your engine.
This is my N52, has 216,000km, and I track this car:
IMG_1468.jpeg
IMG_1467.jpeg
 
sorry i misunderstood what you were saying.what i meant is that my engine is as good as yours! my bad! thanks for the pics! i had mine posted at the past in a bmw forum that no longer exists .
 
But does the engine need a Porsche-speced oil if it's never used in that manner, perhaps only for cruising lazily along the highway or commuting?

I think for some engines the oil has to meet a spec for long drain intervals, but what if you never do a long drain?
Sort of like what AEHass does with his cars. Recommend 60 grade, he uses 5W racing oils instead
 
There was a reply on this website from a member some years back that said something to the affect of are VW's that fragile and need a special oil to hold up? Europe has 746 million people while North America has 579 million. They have their auto industry, testing and standards while we have ours.
Why risk a problem by trying to out think the Engineers in Germany?

Just use an oil which meet the manufacturers spec.
 
Why risk a problem by trying to out think the Engineers in Germany?

Just use an oil which meet the manufacturers spec.
I guess it's about trust or determining when the engineers won out over the accountants/emissions police. Police vehicles fitted with the BMW N57 are catching fire in the UK right? BMW N47/N20 were the latest with timing chain problems, Valve guide seals BMW N-series V8's, Rod bearings on various BMW S-series engines. The list goes on and on.
 
I guess it's about trust or determining when the engineers won out over the accountants/emissions police. Police vehicles fitted with the BMW N57 are catching fire in the UK right? BMW N47/N20 were the latest with timing chain problems, Valve guide seals BMW N-series V8's, Rod bearings on various BMW S-series engines. The list goes on and on.
That’s nothing to do with oil.

That was an issue with the DPF if memory serves.

Likely caused by excessive idling then high speed usage causing a Regen to be requested and the DPF getting too hot.

The MetPolice still have hundreds of diesel BMWs, they are used for Traffic, Area Cars, as Armed Response vehicles and used for SEG (Special Escort Group) convoys.

The BMW Dealer I bought my 745Le from maintains loads of these vehicles, mainly Traffic Cars.
 
That’s nothing to do with oil.

That was an issue with the DPF if memory serves.

Likely caused by excessive idling then high speed usage causing a Regen to be requested and the DPF getting too hot.

The MetPolice still have hundreds of diesel BMWs, they are used for Traffic, Area Cars, as Armed Response vehicles and used for SEG (Special Escort Group) convoys.

The BMW Dealer I bought my 745Le from maintains loads of these vehicles, mainly Traffic Cars.

IJS it speaks to the "trust in engineers" manta as these are all engineering failures. There have been a plethora of EGR (cooling) recalls for the N-series diesels because when they fail the exhaust gases are no longer cooled. The lack of cooling allows these hot gases to perforate (melt) the intake and set fire to other items within the engine bay.

The front main bearings on the S65 go boom because of the upward pressure put on the crank from the timing chains.

Point being we all trust sometimes, sometimes not.
 
Last edited:
ShelB. I don't know if you need to buy the top shel euro motor oils, but doesn't being a member of the expensive European sports car fraternity also include paying the membership fee for maintenance of expensive European sports car's?
 
ShelB. I don't know if you need to buy the top shel euro motor oils, but doesn't being a member of the expensive European sports car fraternity also include paying the membership fee for maintenance of expensive European sports car's?
What makes you think maintenance is more expensive? or oils?
 
When I hear someone talking-up their performance car I ask them where they track it? Usually they don't. Can't explore the boundaries legally on public roads, at least in the US and Canada. But yes, performance Euro cars should get performance Euro oil. It's for a good reason.
 
isn't it? or you using off the shelf Walmart oil like me? :)
I have never heard of shelf Walmart oil.
There are Mobil1, Castrol, Pennzoil, etc. specific ones for "expensive European sports car fraternity" and they are exactly the same price as oil for, idk, Toyota Corolla. Oil filters are the same price, as oil filters for any other car.
 
I have never heard of shelf Walmart oil.
There are Mobil1, Castrol, Pennzoil, etc. specific ones for "expensive European sports car fraternity" and they are exactly the same price as oil for, idk, Toyota Corolla. Oil filters are the same price, as oil filters for any other car.
apparently you didn't notice what is in my Avatar. :)
 
Which European approvals does that oil have?
it doesn't... but it meets Jap car requirement... and EDDYVW was trying to make the point that it doesn't cost more to service a Euro car oil when most people who deal with the stuff know it usually costs more to service European cars.

In general every part for them is more expensive.. just the way it is..
 
To me, it’s high rpm that creates the heat in oil, requiring a higher grade to compensate for a loss of temperature related lower viscosity. The rest is just the European efforts to produce a good oil. They have their pride and don’t feel like bending over to the USA, which by the way is subject to gas mileage requirements promoting the use of lower viscosities. Here’s a bit on CAFE regulated fleet gas mileage requirements.

69859B69-1ADA-48BA-B694-B5FEB006EE43.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top