"Although CI-4 proved to be very good, says Arcy, lubricant makers and engine OEMs found that in some cases the soot being generated by cooled EGR was much higher than expected. In addition, it was almost a different kind of soot, one that thickened the oil much more rapidly. “So we needed to adjust the oil to handle what was happening out in the field,” he adds."
I remember Terry mentioning things to this same effect. Don't know if Terry's comments had this in mind, but it does seem to echo the quote above in regards to certain diesel engines and soot problems.