I live in N Florida and ran M1 AFE 0w-20 it did the job fine. I have M1 HM 10w-30 in there now which is substantially thicker and I can’t tell a difference in the engine. It’s lived on 5w-20 most of its life and now burns some oil.
IndyFan said:Ok, here is a humble questioning of the consensus here that a 5w30 is better for Texas heat, which is an interesting concept, in and of itself, because I'm wondering how 95 degrees in Texas might be different from the same temperature anywhere else, but I guess everything is bigger in Texas, but I digress...
I'm running Mobil 1 AP in my 2018 Jeep. Mobil 1 0w20 has the best flash and pour point performance I've found among their products that would be reasonable for my 3.6 engine. Looking at just the AP oils, which they market as their highest performing oils, I compared the 0w20 to 5w30. The pour point is no surprise, with the 20 weight coming in at -51 C, while the 5w30 comes in at -45. (Still impressive, while not as low.) Here is where it gets interesting and I submit it to the debate. The 0w20 has a higher flash point, at 242, compared to 232. It beats the 5w20, as well, which comes in at 236. (Again, all in Centigrade)
So, it may be more complex than this, but it looks like the 0w20 will handle heat better than the 5w30,as well as flowing at a significantly lower temp. I'm betting there is a higher performing base stock in the 0w20 that makes the difference here, so that's what is going in my engine, even if in the big heat of Texas.
Just for perspective, the advantage is a flash point of 467.6 degrees Fahrenheit for the 0w20 vs. 449.6 for the 5w30, which I take to mean that the 20 has just over 17 degrees of cushion when the 5w30 starts to burn up. Sounds like a big difference, to me.
Just for comparison, Mobil 1 EP 10w30 has a flash point of 232 C, or 449.6 F. Seems to me, again, the 0w20 AP can handle the heat better.
Of course, I am a Mobil 1 customer, but I've not found any other brand that outperforms this ow20 on pour point, flash point, or the full spread. (Amsoil might, but I haven't looked.)
Thoughts?
Interesting, and you make some good points. I'm just curious, have you looked at AFE 0W30? Are you aware that Mobil 1 still doesn't meet the MS6395 Jeep/Chrysler spec your 2018 Jeep warranty calls for? With regard to the 20 grade handling heat better, Ford calls for 50 grade oils in engines that are tracked that normally call for a 20 grade oil in some applications. We've beaten that horse to death here too. I'd venture to say the 20 grade flash point is better than the 50 grade is too, but I haven't looked. Either way they have their reasons, and they had their reasons to bump some engines from an original 20 grade spec to a 30 grade. Many have said it was to reduce warranty claims.
Yep. Aware of all of it. I also know I've had 35 years experience using Mobil 1 oils without a single issue, and I've never seen a common automobile engine harmed by any API certified oil that was in or close to the manufacturer's specified weight, and where there was no contributing design flaw in the engine itself. I also know that political/business reasons are why Mobil 1 oils don't get MS6395 certification. I'm highly confident M1 AP 0w20 would easily exceed the demands of that spec. I'm also fully aware that many dealership put Mobil 1 in Jeeps with their premium oil changes. Mobil 1 has a warranty, anyway. I don't lose sleep over the possibility of failure of that oil.
Finally, I like questioning conventional wisdom. I find it interesting, as sometimes the horse beaten so severely turns out to be the wrong one. In the mean time, I fully expect this engine to do well with AP 0w20 and Fram Ultra filters on whatever OCI the OLM dictates, once I get through my initial break in changes.
I hear ya. I was thinking out loud, and replying to "thoughts?". I ran Mobil 1 in my 08 Liberty for a few years, and have used Mobil 1 probably longer than you. I hate getting old. I had no fear of any engine related issues where the oil I used was going to be the cause. The same can be said for the PU 5W30 I'm currently running. Funny thing is even though the PU is a 30 grade it meets the MS6395 spec, but Chrysler would love to see and wants a 5W20 in the sump.
Originally Posted By: IndyFan
Lol, yeah. I think so much about all this stuff, but I've got a buddy with a mid 90s Tahoe with a 350. He hasn't changed the oil in over a decade. He just keeps adding whatever cheap stuff he has laying around. It has 200k on it and it seems to run ok. I think we're all here just for the fun debate, discussion, and occasional argument. I enjoy the company of people smarter than me and even the occasional smart ***, too.
I wonder, though, why Exxon Mobil bothered to certify Mobil Super Synthetic with Chrysler, but not their flagship oils. Must be some market research data that led them to that.
I had a friend whose father did that with an old Buick in the 70's. They could have used it to fog for mosquitoes.
I'm not sure what XOM was doing with Super vs. their flagship Mobil 1 for the Chrysler spec. It makes me think about PU which was supposed to be Pennzoil's gem, they left a lot of us scratching our heads too.