Originally Posted By: Clevy
Well for short trips wouldn't you want a slightly thicker oil to compensate for fuel dilution. If it's 90% short trip city driven I would assume the oil isn't burning off the inevitable fuel that blows by the rings at start up,until engine is at temp and pistons have expanded.
It's a question so please feel free to inform and not flame me please
No flames are coming from me here. I think your thought processes are quite logical.
Fuel dilution is certainly a factor in short trips, and a thicker oil does help prevent blow-by. Traditionally, you chose a thinner oil for short trips, since the engine won't get too hot and cool thin oil will stay thick. A thicker oil COULD be thinned down by fuel dilution to just the right level, but a thin oil that shears very little might be even better. It's tricky balancing the oil viscosity, formula, and interval for minimal wear.