None of the above
I'd go with a K&N Pro Gold filter from amazon.
they're usually $8 - $15 depending on vehicle.
I have nothing but good to say about KN. Very well constructed filters. I use/used them on 4 vehicles. Love the construction and wrench off nut.
KN Pro Silver is also amazing for shorter OCIs and less severe use. They go for $4-$10 online, again, depending on the vehicle. I use those if i'm too broke for a gold.
I drive down dirt roads frequently, idle, short trips under 5 miles, rural roads going under 50. I oil change every 4K or so with Royal Purple and a KN filter with good results
If you insist on those 3, then Napa platinum can't be beat for a filter bought from a store and not online! Good stuff. Depending on the vehicle, I actually use Napa Golds (Aunt's SUV, Brothers old minivan that use regular ol Dino and have a 3K OCI)
As to Fram, I'm sure they're OK. But their orange filters kind of spoil my image for the rest.
Baldwin.... I've heard the name, never seen one in person