I saw the boxed “Subaru“ oil filter today at Wally’s. Opened the box, and inside was a shrinkwrapped blue 15208aa150 filter looking all normal and genuine. Since I need a “…12a” filter, I closed the box back up and didn’t bother to notice the price. Next stop was the local dealer. I had called ahead and asked about the 15208aa12a filter…”oh yeah, we have plenty of those, but we’ll put your name on one if you’re coming in.” When I arrived, they said they placed it back since I was much later than anticipated, getting there just a bit before they closed. So they went back and brought out one of the new “generic“ blue filters…not shrink wrapped. Meanwhile, there was a classic shrink-wrapped blue filter on the counter where things were accumulating to be picked up. I asked if that one was ”mine,” they said no. But after I told them I didn’t want the unwrapped one (no wrap, no box, no markings), and asked if I could buy the classic one on the counter instead, they agreed. Leaving with my “genuine“ (Fram) 15208aa12a, I asked myself: why did I make such a fuss over a glorified Fram paper-end-capped filter. Hmmmph.
I will say, the generic one had the appropriate rounded “o-ring” like gasket, but a plastic inner cage, and a black ADBV. Who knows, might have been better than the blue Fram. reminded me of the FarSide cartoon with two doors: labeled “****ed if you do,“ & “****ed if you don’t” and the devil saying come’on, come’on, it’s either one or the other.