Just wanted to give an update on what I wound up with. Initially I ordered those General Altimax RT45's that were linked above and after spending a good while dealing with Walmart and their order screw up I cancelled and returned them since they showed up 1 by 1. I did keep 1 of those and bought a full size steel wheel and made a full size spare out of it. I did wind up buying those Summit Ultramax A/S tires and I mounted and balanced them today and I am really surprised with them honestly. The car has never driven so straight and the ride and noise is way better than the old tires were even when new and the steering response is better as well. As far as my static bubble balance job it seems pretty good. 1 tire balanced perfect with no weight at all, 2 of them balanced fine with the weights from the old tires and the last one balanced in the same spot with a little less weight than what it had. It's as smooth as it ever was with the old tires that were spin balanced by discount tire. Nice and smooth up to 70, a little bit of shake at 75 but nothing bad, it wasn't a good stretch of highway either.
View attachment 207032View attachment 207033
The General for the spare, glad I don't have to worry about relying on a 25 year old donut spare anymore.