Recent Topics
Spiral dynamics of the solar system
by jrustles
09/02/14 01:36 PM
Imminent Terrorist Attack Warning
by friendly_jacek
09/02/14 01:36 PM
Fast food workers plan Thursday strike f
by LT4 Vette
09/02/14 01:15 PM
GM To Install Eye/Head Tracking Systems in Autos.
by sleddriver
09/02/14 12:42 PM
STP Global Extended Life coolant?
by bullwinkle
09/02/14 12:25 PM
coolant mix
by BigD7
09/02/14 11:59 AM
First time post, looking for thoughts on UOA
by Streetside
09/02/14 11:51 AM
Polaris ranger 570 efi?
by tinman11
09/02/14 11:48 AM
5k OCI on Hyundai Sonata 2.0 Turbo
by syn_all_the_way
09/02/14 11:36 AM
Replaced cracked flexplate 95 Toyota T100
by chestand
09/02/14 11:19 AM
Snow tire/made in USA rant
by faramir9
09/02/14 11:13 AM
2011 Ram 1500 Differential and Transfer Case
by JasonK94Z
09/02/14 10:17 AM
Newest Members
SparkSVT, grumpyoldman, jbl_91762, PapasGuy, fanie
51170 Registered Users
Who's Online
103 registered (901Memphis, 3800Series, AandPDan, 123Saab, abycat, 9 invisible), 1972 Guests and 220 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
51170 Members
64 Forums
218681 Topics
3448299 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 >
Topic Options
#1855050 - 04/12/10 05:48 PM 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
I purchased a pipe cutter at Canadian Tire today so I can finally open those sub 3inch diameter subaru filters. There are two official filters below, the black Tokyo Roki and the Quaker State 14612, and 3 others that are a little longer and work on the subaru.

We'll start with the slightly longer options. First off a FRAM PH7317:










Next up the Pennzoil PZ09, aka Purolator Classic:













Next is a Napa Professional 1356, aka Napa Gold:







_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855053 - 04/12/10 05:50 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
Andrew MKZ Offline


Registered: 10/04/09
Posts: 2811
Loc: USA
That fram looks great.

They all do.
_________________________
2010 Lincoln MKZ
23,500 miles

Formerly DT466E_bus

Top
#1855063 - 04/12/10 05:57 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: Andrew MKZ]
chad8 Offline


Registered: 08/26/09
Posts: 1251
Loc: michigan
can I wear gloves too?

Top
#1855067 - 04/12/10 06:02 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
ARCOgraphite Offline


Registered: 05/17/09
Posts: 8445
Loc: N.H, U.S.A.
Thx, WEBFORS, I can smell the clean, crisp Canadian air blowing right through those photos! The wix/napa cartridge looks tiny, and the 51356 is the larger one for ACURA, Nissan, Mitsu application IIRC? I'm stuck with the SOA OEM 12A blue fram cans till warranty is up; if the car wasnt knocking and I wasn't worried about throwing a moving part out of the engine, Id run something else wink
_________________________
2014 Nissan Note S 5MT, OC#0 170mi-FACTORY 5W30+Nissan China Filter
2014 Forester 6MT 5Door, OC#0 540mi-FACTORY 0W20(?)+TokyoRoki 160 Filter

Top
#1855069 - 04/12/10 06:04 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
Here are the two 'officially' spec'd filters for the Forester:



First the QS 14612, aka Purolator Classic:








Next is the Tokyo Roki 15208AA100:













And all the filters lined up side by side. From left to right we have the P Classic 14612, Tokyo Roki, P Classic 14610, Fram PH7317, and finally the Napa Gold 1356:




_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855079 - 04/12/10 06:10 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
I'll be honest, I was more impressed with the spec'd filters (the QS and Tokyo Roki). They were very well made, lots of solid even pleats and no sign of degradation.

By looking at the pics above, it's hard to make an argument in favor of a larger/longer filter when the smaller ones appear to have just as much, maybe even more, media. The small height of the Tokyo Roki and the QS (aka Purolator Classic) and tight even pleats makes for very sturdy filter media. I was expecting less from the Classic and was expecting the Tokyo Roki to be a much better filter. When in fact, they are very close and I would choose one or the other depending on price. Since the P Classic is the only available of the two (The roki is discontinued), and the fact that it's much less expensive, would win my vote of all the filters in the line up.
_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855092 - 04/12/10 06:18 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: chad8]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
Originally Posted By: chad8
can I wear gloves too?


Only if you want to be super awesome like me!! grin
_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855099 - 04/12/10 06:22 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: ARCOgraphite]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
Originally Posted By: ARCOgraphite
Thx, WEBFORS, I can smell the clean, crisp Canadian air blowing right through those photos! The wix/napa cartridge looks tiny, and the 51356 is the larger one for ACURA, Nissan, Mitsu application IIRC? I'm stuck with the SOA OEM 12A blue fram cans till warranty is up; if the car wasnt knocking and I wasn't worried about throwing a moving part out of the engine, Id run something else wink


Nothing wrong with the Napa gold. It's a very well made filter with lots of tight pleats. The P Classic 14610 and PH7317 are definitely taller than the Napa gold, so if I had to choose one of the three it would be the P Classic. But in the Subaru application you get to use these smaller filters like the Roki and P Classic 14612 which appear to be very well made, and IMHO I would choose them over the taller "oversized" options.
_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855130 - 04/12/10 06:39 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
Soobs Offline


Registered: 08/14/09
Posts: 240
Loc: Virginia, USA
Wow, that pipe cutter did a great job. Any trouble with it? I may need to pick one of those up.

All the filters look fine to me. I continue to use the Honeywell 15208AA12A on my Forester. They do great too.

Did you notice any different sounds or vibrations between all of them with cold start-ups or normal operation?

Top
#1855138 - 04/12/10 06:42 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: webfors]
drewjp Offline


Registered: 05/05/06
Posts: 563
Loc: Michigan
I like the Tokyo Roki the best out of these. Appears to be very well assembled.
_________________________
2002 Chrysler PT Cruiser Limited
GC 0W-30

Top
#1855142 - 04/12/10 06:46 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: drewjp]
mrfish Offline


Registered: 01/09/08
Posts: 56
Loc: SoCal
I like your tool! Where can I get one?
_________________________
04 Ram 1500 QC
13 Hyundai Sonata
05 Mustang Conv
06 Pontiac Solstice
06 Chevy Tahoe

Top
#1855194 - 04/12/10 07:19 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: mrfish]
cjcride Offline


Registered: 11/06/09
Posts: 586
Loc: Ontario Canada
Home Depot, plumbing dept.
_________________________
2004 Corolla



Top
#1855195 - 04/12/10 07:19 PM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: mrfish]
AuthorEditor Offline


Registered: 05/30/08
Posts: 1405
Loc: New York
What, no PureOne PL14610 or PL14459? I like the silicone ADBV and the better media.

Top
#1855628 - 04/13/10 05:54 AM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: Soobs]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
Originally Posted By: Soobs
Wow, that pipe cutter did a great job. Any trouble with it? I may need to pick one of those up.

All the filters look fine to me. I continue to use the Honeywell 15208AA12A on my Forester. They do great too.

Did you notice any different sounds or vibrations between all of them with cold start-ups or normal operation?


The new pipe cutter is easier to use than the two 'oil filter cutters' I've purchased over the past year. Cost was $40 with a lifetime warranty from Canadian Tire since it's a Motomaster product.

I noticed no difference in engine operation with any of the filters, except the Fram and Napa, since neither of those have been used by me. The Fram came off the Honda Civic belonging to a friend.

The Subaru OEM filter made by Honeywell appears to be well made. However, I can buy the P Classic for $4 in Ogdensburg (upstate NY), so I'll most likely be buying a stash of those on my next trip over the bridge grin
_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
#1855629 - 04/13/10 05:56 AM Re: 5 different Subaru filter options - cut open pics [Re: drewjp]
webfors Offline


Registered: 06/06/06
Posts: 3621
Loc: Ottawa
Originally Posted By: drewjp
I like the Tokyo Roki the best out of these. Appears to be very well assembled.


Agreed. It is the filter that impressed me the most. The depth of media, number of pleats, bonding, etc. And it was the smallest filter of the bunch. So it's impressive that Tokyo Roki could fit that much filter in such a small can.
_________________________
08 Forester 5mt, Edge 10w30, XG7317
13 Dodge GC, VWB 5w20/10w30 mix, PClassic OF
13 Suzuki SFV650, OEM 10w40, OEM OF
All small engines; RT5 10w30

Top
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 >