I would say Valvoline Maxlife has more moly and boron. However Im not sure if that will make a difference over the Quaker State HM. Valvoline Maxlife isnt Dexos whereas Quaker State HM is Dexos.
The Quaker.State formula seems more robust versus the store brand "SuperTech".
If buying.the 12 quart box for $58 the Valvoline is about $4.83 per quart. The Quaker State HM is about $3.8 per quart.
The Valvoline Maxlife is the better formula but the best value is the Quaker State HM.