I agree! I told myself if I were to buy an extended warranty, it would only be through Mopar.
When it came down to it, my miles-per-year kinda dictated either the Lifetime plan or none at all (About 6K miles per year, the year/mileage extended warranties would run out of time LONG before the miles because the "years" start when the factory warranty starts, so Lifetime was the only "good" choice if I wanted one)
Buying online the MaxCare Lifetime warranty with 100.00 deductible was $2600. Between the possible cam/lifter issues, expensive 8 speed ZF transmission and numerous "expensive" computer modules, I bought the warranty.
The fuel level sensor (of all things...when was the last time you had that happen?) died a few months ago. For $100 the dealer replaced the whole fuel sending unit (sensors, pump, etc). Would have been about a $900.00 fix, so Im now at about $1700 paid for the warranty.
And since the dealer did it, AFAIK that instance is covered for 12 months/12K miles so if it dies again I dont even have to pay the deductible.
Would I buy it again? Not sure. Mopar discontinued the lifetime plan shortly after I bought it. Ive heard they may bring it back in the future, but Im guessing it will be a lot more expensive. My actual dealer tried to sell me a year-based MaxCare plan for almost 5K so 2600 for Lifetime was a bargain IMHO.