Tim H,
It's the transmission shifter.*shrugs* At about 2500 miles, neutral becomes difficult to "find". Also, the lifters clickity clack gets pretty loud by this mileage too. Victory recommends 20w-40 semi syn. claiming it contains a coolant to help regulate engine temp. Odd that their oil is not jaso ma, api or sae certified. However, At $60.00 their oil kit gets you 6 quarts of oil, 1 oil filter and a copper gasket. I own a 2009 Kingpin & I have only used their oil (18k miles) and will post the UOA. If I could find Rotella 15w-40 semi syn, I'd try it. All 2011 Victory models have a new transmission shifter cam that allow 5000 mile oil changes. I use Rotella 15w-40 in my Honda Shadow and it works great.