Well yes the lifetime update is not what a consumer would expect, because all over the box they sell it with lifetime updates. Apparently deep deep in the bowels of their fine print a "lifetime is 4 years" as they define it. Deceptive and an outright lie IMO. Any a gps it works fine even with the old maps so I figure I have gotten more than my $$ worth out of it and will probably still be able to use it for a few more years before it becomes a paper weight. Could buy a new GPS but really would rather spend my money on important stuff like hops for my beer maker.