Originally Posted By: JOD
Personally, I hate this car--and I while I guess the sales numbers will ultimately decide, I think GM is completely missing the boat.
The "ultra-compact SUV" is a ridiculous idea on its face. It's a higher, slower, less fuel-efficient version of the Cruze hatchback--with the added bonus of dramatically decreased utility since it's harder to load stuff on the roof.
There are an increasing number of good 5 door options out there; the new Impreza, the Focus 5 door, new Mazda 3. All of these offer similar room, but much better performance since they're pushing less weight and have better aerodynamics. Sorry, but this car seems like a loser to me. Obviously, I'm biased towards wagons, and this is the anti-wagon.
I'm willing to bet that if GM brought in the Cruze 5 door, they'd discover what other companies have already figured out: hatchbacks sell when you offer them-
LINK. Instead, they're foisting this bloated thing on people. No thanks. It almost seems that they're purposely avoiding bringing in the Cruze hatchback to try and force people 'up-market'. Fortunately, there are other options out there.
While I don't disagree that hatchbacks and wagons have an inherent utility and styling (this is subjective) advantage over their sedan counterparts, I'm gonna have to disagree about them welling *well*.
Did you read the article? Hatches sell well in the subcompact market and that's about it. Mazda 3? More sedans sold. Jetta vs. Golf? More Jettas sold. Focus hatch vs. sedan? More sedans sold. Anything larger than a compact wagon or hatch is all but extinct. As you go up in size, the buyers stop looking for that utility factor. Why? Because if they want utility, they buy an SUV or crossover!
Now, on to the Buick.
It's not a large vehicle. As a comparison, it is 6" taller than a Mazda 3 hatch. As a reference, that's the same height as an HHR. The Encore has a 3" shorter wheelbase and is 9" shorter overall when compared to a Mazda 3 hatch. A loaded up Mazda 3 hatch with an auto weighs 3,100 lbs. A FWD Encore weighs 3,200 lbs.
It's a a little bit smaller than an HHR and has about the same power as the 2.2L did. I'm not seeing how this is an OMG overweight, bloated monstrosity that is so underpowered it's not even able to do freeway speeds. The numbers say otherwise.
Dramatically decreased utility when loading things on the roof because of the height? Seriously? Besides the fact it's no taller than an HHR, which isn't tall, the Mazda 3 doesn't even have roof rails! Nor does the Focus or the Golf. How much utility is present when the manufacturer doesn't think it's worthwhile to
even put a roof rack on?
You're bummed you can't buy a Cruze hatch. OK. Say that. Don't make up reasons to hate on the Buick though.
The Cruze hatch doesn't have roof rails either