Aye, there's the rub. I think the current Crosstrek and Outback look fine with the cladding. Especially the Crosstrek, where the cladding makes for a more aggressive and rugged looking vehicle which is really nothing more than a lifted Impreza (I've yet to see the new Wilderness versions of either). But yeah, what works on an SUV doesn't necessarily translate well on a sports sedan.It's like they chose to style the WRX like the rest of the lineup instead of a japanese sports sedan. I recently saw one of these in the "wild" (costco) and i really could not decide if i thought it was the ugliest thing ever or the coolest thing ever. It looked both good and bad at the same time. I had to slowly walk all around it. Tons of cladding, lots of lift, very black and white looking. The example i found was brand new and perfectly detailed. I imagine after all the plastics fade it will look worse.
The Outback Wilderness in white:
Automakers are notorious for taking design cues from whatever is selling well and suddenly putting it all over the rest of the lineup. Remember when Chevy decided all it's cars needed the same prominent brushed aluminum horizontal bar across the grille, just like on its trucks? They didn't used to have that bar on their cars, but since the trucks had it, then everything else must follow suit. Ford too.... They've pushed the "Ka" concept car through various parts of their lineup, only to abandon it and replace it with Fusion lookalikes, etc, etc. Imagine a Mustang styled like the "Ka" concept car!