Yes, I used to work quite a bit with UOA with electrical transformers and switchgear. I have absolutely total faith in the concept of oil analysis, and the ability of lubricants to 'last' for extended drains. Speaking of extended drains, many of the transformers were/are on their factory fills of oil 40, 50 years later, with filtering occurring once every 7 years or so, guided by a UOA program.quote:
Originally posted by berge:
since honda is now recommending a 10000mile/1yr OCI, WITH DINO!!!, I have absolutely no fear of doing 1X/year oil changes with M1 or XD-3.quote:
Originally posted by pitzel:
Many of the contemporary recommendations, for example, against extending drains of Mobil1 come from Mobil itself, even though UOA shows that Mobil1 is rarely 'due' for a change at the manufacturer's recomended intervals.
I'm still chicken though, I change the oil 2X a year, when I'm changing back and forth the snow tires and wheels.
Of course, instead of looking for 'wear metals', we looked at statistics such as moisture, dielectric strength, and dissolved gases such as hydrogen, acetylene, as well as oil decomposition components.
Recently a lot of the transformers have been fitted with real-time instrumentation that can be read from a distance through a computer modem. The oil we used was called 'Voltesso', manufactured in Sarnia, and delivered oil tanker at a time directly to our jobsites.
When oil disposal, especially PCB-laden oil disposal is such a huge concern, the only choice is to keep the oil in service as long as possible. So a UOA, even at $500-$600 per sample, including labour and transportation, still remained a good investment.