Originally Posted by andreigbs
Couple notes of caution: make sure the electronic steering column lock issue has been taken care of, or that you're capable of repairing yourself. When (not if) it goes, the steering column is locked, stuck, you're unable to even start the car and will have to get it towed to the MB dealer where they'll take about 2 grand from you to fix it.
It's funny because we have 4 W204 models in the family, and my buddy has one as well, and none of them have had the EIS issue. Two are 2008, mine is 2009, and two are 2010 models. Two manuals, three automatics, all over 120k miles on them.
To be honest, they have collectively had very few issues to speak of. My W204 has been one of the best cars I've owned and will continue to own since it literally drives like a brand new car even at 11 years old.
Originally Posted by andreigbs
One other thing is the manual transmission (at least on mine) is quite notchy, not what I would call a smooth shifting job. You have to really be careful and time the rowing just right since you're pushing quite a bit of heft around from gear to gear. Crunching may result.
Very interesting to hear this. Mine shifts absolutely perfectly even all these years later, both in very hot weather and in temperatures well below freezing. No crunching except maybe for the first two shifts from first to second on a cold winter morning. No rubbery feel either. I definitely do not have to be "careful" under any circumstance other than knowing how to properly operate a manual transmission. Maybe yours is out of adjustment, or your shifter bushings are shot, or the clutch wasn't disengaging properly. Also worth noting, these cars come factory filled with fully synthetic 75W gear oil (straight 75W, very thin). If anything else is put in them, they grind and balk when shifting (don't ask me how I know, aka dealer screw up). Mine is great, as is my buddies which I've driven many times. Both compare very favorably to my brother's manual Bimmer.
Originally Posted by andreigbs
The last item is to be wary of a known issue with what sounds like bearing knock on a cold start, for only a couple seconds. The M272 engine needed slightly thicker bearings and some owners had theirs replaced under warranty.
One of our 2008's has this all the time, and the others occasionally depending on temperature (mostly in the summer in between short stops). The rod bearings knock for a split second because the lower mains are slightly oversize. This causes the rod bearings to wait a second longer for full oil flow. The dealer up here very kindly offered to fix any of them we wanted fixed under warranty, but I was not going to have them tear into my perfectly good factory built engine to replace main bearing shells for some esthetic problem. After 11-12 years and 120k miles, nothing has worsened at all nor I'm I worried in the slightest bit about longevity.