I agree with you, it was puzzling. But let me give you an example, my 95 PSD in the winter just hates to run the first 5 minutes without synthetic.(Plugging it in, I can run any oil though, but not always available). And it is not that cold here, in the teens once in a while. I have found Amsoil 15W40 and now Royal Purple 15W40 work sweet in it. In my 01 PSD I think I could run molasses in the winter and it would run good.
I have an 82 Caddy with 7,200 miles on it. I tried 10W40 HM Valvoline and it ran weird at start up for about 3 minutes. (Got it free with the rebate back in Nov/Dec) I went to 10W30 and it is like butter now.
People think it is weird, but look at the posts on here about different oils in various autos. I have seen where 0W30 GC made a newer GM act funny with a Vortec 350. And the same oil in a Honda/Mazda made it like a new car. So individual engines have different personalities. And I seem to get the ones that are the anomaly.
Sorry that I got so far off topic.