Make that the 5th time's the charm. I pulled it out of the garage to take pictures of it, and noticed the roof was still covered in overspray. But they buffed it out yesterday and it was shiny and not rough like before so I didn't notice it. I took it back into the body shop this morning and they used a clay bar and it came off, looks good now. I don't have any pictures of the roof afterwards, just before. You can see the tape lines.