Originally Posted By: sciphi
Originally Posted By: Nick1994
How long do you plan on driving the car? The hybrid at 42 mpg will save you only $476 in gas per year over the standard 25 mpg (combined) version. I looked online and the hybrid version is usually at least $5,000 more than the standard version. It would take 10-1/2 years just to break even in fuel costs to pay for the hybrid version.
And then there's the cost of it potentially needing a battery.
Change the question to "How many miles per year do you plan on driving the car" and the answer will make more sense. Not everybody drives 12,000 miles a year. For folks who drive 25-30k miles a year, a hybrid makes a lot more sense, even with today's low gas prices. Longer range and less time spent filling up or looking for gas. That's important for folks who travel long distances or live in rural areas.
Depending on what a person does for a living, they can't show up in even a higher-trim Prius. Sends the wrong signal to a customer or prospective customer. Nothing wrong with showing up in a loaded Fusion Hybrid since it doesn't look like a fuel-sipping hybrid. Not everybody wants to or can afford to show off their "green" credentials. Believe it or not, there are still quite a few people who absolutely will not listen to anything said by anybody stepping out of a Prius. If that person happens to be a prospective customer, too bad.
For the battery argument, the number of batteries replaced on parallel hybrids like a Fusion Hybrid are pretty darned low. Low single digits low. The warranty on the battery is also pretty long. By the time the average FFH will need a battery, the rest of the car will likely be ready for the junkyard. Or there will be used/rebuilt batteries available. It's basically a non-issue.
I used 15,000 miles per year in my calculation which is what the average person drives. Seeing as how the hybrid version first came out in 2013, those batteries are still new. If he drives 15k miles a year and it takes 10-1/2 years for it to break even and the battery dies at 10 years old, that factors in as well. If it's $2,000 for a new battery then that's 4 more years for it to break even again when all along he could have just gotten a gas version and not have had to worry about it.