Ok ok ok.... I feel kinda like I have egg on my face, but I wanted to return to this thread and give an update on my "old gas" as it was part of the root problem of a very rough-running Verado 175 this last Saturday.
To re-cap:
I acquired a 2016 Ranger 190LS. It had been sitting for 2 years. The previous owner used only non-ethanol gas and said he put some Stabil in with every fill-up.
I didn't have to deal with nearly 50 gallons, but there was about 15 gallons in the tank. I pumped it out with a $7 HF transfer pump and some 1/2" OD clear tube. I pumped it into three 5-gallon gas jugs.
The gas was clear and smelled "good". I've always heard of bad gas "smelling", but this smelled just like fresh gas.
I've since put 10 of those 15 gallons in 3 of my vehicles and they are running fine. I put it on top of nearly full tanks, so it is diluted.
I suggest you find a way to pump it out and analyze it, maybe pour some in a clear jar and let it sit for an hour. If it smells like normal gas and is clear after sitting, I think you'd be fine burning it in a normal vehicle.
This was my post above. I did what was 90% of a 300 hour service on this engine, oil/filter, lower unit gear oil, fuel filter, fuel/water castle filter, drive belt. I did not replace the thermostat and I did not order spark plugs. I pulled the top of the 4 plugs on this engine and it looked fairly good. This is an in-line 4 and has NGK Iridium plugs factory installed. This engine has 50 hours or less on it.
It had been sitting for 2+ years.
The engine would fire right up and run/idle. It did spit/sputter ONE time for 1 second when I cranked it up at home on ear muffs after the service work. When I trailered it to the lake, I felt like I was having a tough time getting it off the trailer using the motor. The boat was floating except for the far front. I was at 3/4 throttle in reverse and it barely squeaked off the trailer. I wrote it up and I needed the trailer 4-6" farther in the water.
I backed up and I wasn't far from the dock, but it seem like I was a 9 year old who had never driven a boat before trying to dock this thing. I didn't realize it at the time, but I think it was extremely poor performance of the engine giving me fits trying to steer/move the boat. I noticed that when I put it in gear, the engine would vibrate like crazy. The whole boat was shaking. I was instantly distraught, thinking I didn't get something back together right on the lower end. I left it at the marina and asked them to 'figure it out".
They called Wednesday about 1:00 pm. Said it needs new plugs and I needed to "run that boat hard". I explained that I had never run it, just got it, it had been sitting two years. The service manager said "ahhh, it all makes sense now!!!". They said a lot of the vibration had gone away with new plugs but it was still there, they were talking to Mercury about it. Turns out it was dirty fuel injectors. They cleaned them and he called back and said "it runs like a scalded dog now. You're going to really like this boat."
So... I now say get the old gas out and run the engine ASAP with some fresh gas and possible a bottle or two of OTC fuel injector cleaner.
The old gas seemed to burn fine in my vehicles, but it was diluted pretty good, 3-5 gallons to 15 gallons of fresh gas.