Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
Quote:
confused ... define "realized pump output". If you mean the oil pressure after the filter, then yes that would be the delta P across the filter. So what was your filter delta P measured value when your oil pump was putting out 82 psi in relief mode?
In relief a % of flow "fits" in the engine. This % of flow will equal that % of pressure.
Simply stated. IF 1gpm=100psi of pressure (use a figure that's convenient for the demonstration -whatever visc ..whatever this that or the other thing as long as it works in your head) then .5gpm would develop 50psi.
Can you agree to that? Now first it helps if you want to see what I'm saying.
I may not be communicating it well.
Take these points in isolation. We should be able to integrate them at the end.
I don't think the flow volume (gpm) vs. pressure relationship is very linear, but for this discussion let's assume it is.
Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
That's why a bypass valve is there. To prevent the filter from showing its TRUE resistance/restriction to flow and starving the engine of oil. Now there are higher bypass rated valves on some engines, but that's factored by the OEM (VW/AUDI/etc) ..but your typical filter can develop NO MORE than 15+/- PSID to inhibit flow to the engine.
Yes, the bypass valve is there to prevent the filter from starving the engine IF it becomes overly clogged. It is also there to protect the filter media from blowing out if the psid becomes too great. If it never becomes very dirty, the psid will remain low throughout it's life ... near the same psid it had when brand new. That brand new psid is what I consider the baseline psid for any filter, as debris loading varies in every car and usage. Yes, if a filter has a 15 psi bypass valve, then it should not have a psid higher than 15 when in bypass (if the bypass valve can flow all the oil that needs to be bypassed).
Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
Try this on for size and see if you can agree with this scenario as stated. Don't worry about how we got there ..don't worry about this or that, just see if you can understand me for this example IN ISOLATION ..it doesn't have to have ANY practical application ..it's just for conceptual view.
We have a super duper filter ..titanium can...rebar reinforced media that's a titanium wire mesh.
We have our 100psi relief level pump.
Now ..in whatever manner possible ..whatever visc required ..whatever flow rate ...(doesn't matter)
What are your readings across the filter when 50% of the pump output is being relieved? Now you first have to accept the given that 50% of the pump output is NOT going to the engine and 50% of the pump output IS.
Assuming the pump is in relief at 100 psi, it's not going to be a 50 psid across the filter because again the filter is not as restrictive as an engine's oiling system. The pressure drop from the pump's 100 psi supply to 0 psi (atmospheric pressure in the sump) must be dropped across every flow component starting from the inlet of the oil filter to the sump. Consider the oil filter as component #1 and the entire engine as component #2.
The answer also depends on what the actual flow volume (gpm) is going through the filter & engine with the pump at 100 psi. If the engine is super restrictive, there might only be 3 gpm going through the filter, which means the filter psid will be pretty low. If there is 12 gpm going through the filter because the engine bearings, etc are super loose and not very flow restrictive then the filter will have around a 5 or 6 psid.
There is not enough information in your example to determine any real answer - I threw in some numbers to show why. If you could say that 10 gpm is going through the filter & engine at 100 psi pump pressure, then it might have a solution.
Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
What would gauges look like above and below the filter. The filter has NO BYPASS and was designed to withstand 50000PSID.
What do you get?
It depends on how much gpm volume is going through the filter and engine. The gpm flow going through the filter and engine is determined on their flow resistance and the pump's supply pressure - and of course if the pump can "keep up" with the flow demand at its pressure relief pressure.
Knowing the flow resistance ratio between filter and engine can give you an indication on how the pressure readings will be. Assuming the pump is in relief at 100 psi.
If the engine is 15 times more restrictive than the filter, the filter would have a 6.7 psid. The pressure above the filter would be 100 psi, and 93.3 psi after the filter (engine oil pressure).
If the engine is 30 times more restrictive than the filter, the filter would have a 3.3 psid. The pressure above the filter would be 100 psi, and 96.7 psi after the filter (engine oil pressure).