Originally Posted By: raytseng
Originally Posted By: Benito
The doctor should know that and carry out tests accordingly.
Big assumption here.
IF your only evidence is the doctor should know this, hate to break it to you, but that's not how it works in the US.
Studies and reports about 25% of medical charges nationwide is found to be unneeded and unnecessary treatment. There is about $750B in what is considered completely unnecessary treatment in the US-meaning tests or procedures run where the most up-to-date current studies say are useless. (BTW) This is the same as the entire education budget on just wasted and useless work. So you are NOT an unique case, and this is something you as a consumer need to be more aware of.
Doctor's DON'T know things are unnessary, they error on the side of caution and tests that come up negative don't register on their radar, they just run them.
Unfortunately, they are NOT resposible for knowing this is unnessary, YOU as the patient and the insurance are responsible for signing off on any procedures and the bills. Did you sign any paperwork before the visit? I am sure it's buried in there that if your insurance doesn't pay, you have to pay. If you don't agree to that, you instead have to be careful to ask them to pre-authorize everything with insurance, otherwise they'll run wild with charges.
It's the same as you just drop your car off at a true Stealership for service and say just fix everything. They're going to replace and change every single thing whether it helps or not.
If after the work is done, you later say, "hey I only wanted what was in the scheduled service manual, my work only covers scheduled services, I'm not paying for this other work". Too bad. The horse is already out and the work is already done, and they're going to point out that you already signed off on the work order before they began.
The problem is not illegal or a scam, and you and the insurance are left on the hook as being responsible.
Part of the reason for the trouble is the conservative political cry who said, don't get in between me and my doctor; and don't put in big government and beuracrats and death panels are deciding my health.
And so the doctors just run wild with test cause someone else is going to pay for it, and they don't have oversight with respect to COSTS, only oversight on patient outcomes.
It's so common and severe, that medicare threw into ACA that doctors can form medical practice groups to work directly with them, and also the 2nd part that if practice group is able to reduce costs, they gets to KEEP a % of the savings to encourage them to change behavior not run unnecessary tests, procedures, and instead get the patients healthy.
They did not and could not say what the doctors were doing was wrong or bad because technically it was not illegal or wrong! The doctors know best but just aren't thinking about costs. They're just thinking about your health.
So what they did was completely legal, not a scam, and they had to encourage better behavior through financial mechanisms rather than legal ones.
If you want articles on this, there came from a New Yorker, but each are like 20pages long, so doubt folks are truly interested in learning about the issues with healthcare.
Google "McAllen health care" if you want details.
Every other doctor that I or any member of my family has been to knows precisely which tests are to be performed at what frequency and at what age during an annual check up.
Consequently, no charge has ever been denied by any insurance company.
In this instance, the insurance company denied the charge because it was not "usual and customary".
There was absolutely no consultation nor any word from the doctor that this test was a separate item in the visit. They just went ahead and did it during the overall checkup.