I ended up buying Cooper Lifeliner tires last night.
Cost per rated mile (50000)was $.0001 more per mile than the next cheapest, the Cooper CS3(65000).
A friend of mine recently put these on his car and they seem to be a good all season tire - much better in the snow than the CS4 they replaced. I don't plan on driving them in the snow as I run dedicated winter tires, but never know when you are going to get caught in a freak snow storm.
Once I get them mounted I'll bring them to Walmart to balance and then get an alignment done on the car.