Originally Posted by irv
Originally Posted by supton
Originally Posted by Nick1994
I'm pretty sure the master cylinder is somewhat vented.
Fluid level drops as brake pads wear, it's got to go somewhere.
Not only that but the worst fluid seems to wind up in the cylinders. I think it slowly migrates in through the seal on the piston.
To be fair, a great deal of cars are on the road with 10+ year old brake fluid in them. And I've had to replace calipers that were less than 10 years old, some of which had brake fluid changes on schedule. I still think brake fluid is cheap, and flushing easy, and the recommendation came about for a reason.
I'm certainly not going to tell anyone to not maintain their brakes, even if that means changing their brake fluid annually, or whenever they feel like it, but like you said, I think the majority of vehicles on the roads nowadays have never changed their brake fluid, ever.
I could understand if there were documented cases of failed/spent brake fluid but I don't recall ever reading any of those? Some manus recommend it while some don't? I find that odd. unless the brake fluid for those that don't is something extremely special, but I don't think that exists?
The same fluid is used here and on the other side of the pond, in very similar designed systems. So it seems dubious that it's required on some vehicles yet not on others. But I suppose that's in the same vein as to thick vs thin motor oil in the manual--who's right?
I've noticed a change in pedal firmness after a fluid change, and the fluid coming out is darker. If moisture can migrate in past the rubber seals, then so can air too. Ergo, corrosion can occur. Regular fluid changes might keep moisture content low (by diffusion) to mitigate problems, or stave them off for the next owner.