Originally Posted By: Smokescreen
You can drive in winter, terrible conditions with an "all season" tire and likely have no problem. I have done it. Like others have said you can have good drivers, bad drivers, drivers with good tread, others with bald tread.
What it really boils down to is if you are looking for the "extra" margin when driving in winter conditions:
Winter Tires provide a better, safer, more stable handling driving experience than "all season" can when compared side by side. Its been proven over and over gain. If you are willing to pay the premium for this extra margin, then you have that option. I have been in enough situations to feel that for me winter tires are worth it. Others may not.
So much depends on the vehicle, how and when it is used, what kind of roads it's driven on, how well the roads are treated in your area, whether much late-night driving is required and whether you _have_ to get to work in foul weather.
Fer instance: A few years back, I bought Nokian Hakka Rsi's (forerunner of the R) for my Chevy (Malibu) Classic. I worked as a reporter for a local daily paper, part of my coverage area was in the hills of the Poconos and if news broke out up there I had to cover it, even at night. The difference in conditions between the foothills of the Poconos and near the top of the mountain---12 miles as the birds fly---can be stark.
I can't say there was a time when the Nokians clearly saved me from sliding off the road or having an accident, but they sure helped my peace of mind and confidence level---and top safe speed---as I rushed around the hills in the dark, in a rush for deadline. I considered it money well spent---and even then they were not cheap.
The next winter, I no longer worked at the paper and did not need to drive as much: certainly not as much at night or in the hills. I debated whether to put the Hakkas on again or sell them, as they still had good tread. Then a friend, who lives in the hills I mentioned, off a semi-back road, got a job in town that required her to work late and drive home uphill at night. Her boss was nice, but expected employees to show up for work as long as the place was open....plus she drove a Jetta VR6, not a great winter vehicle despite FWD and ABS. Powerful engine, tight suspension, etc.
I gave her the Nokians as a combined holiday/birthday gift. She reported the same thing I did: She did not think she ever would have literally crashed for lack of the Hakkas, but they helped a great deal---enough for an ordinary driver to notice---when the roads were slopped up and slick. Plus it eased her mind no end.
This winter I am content with my new Hankook H727s. They did great in the first two snow storms; I think TR test results and most driver reviews are correct: They are a very good winter tire, for an A/S. If I had more $$$ to spare I would have gotten winter tires, probably on their own steelies, but for now I am content.
If I get another job that requires travel w/out the option at night up in the hills, on roads that are not at the top of the priority list for plowing/treating....then I will find a way to afford snow tires again.
So, it all depends.
You can drive in winter, terrible conditions with an "all season" tire and likely have no problem. I have done it. Like others have said you can have good drivers, bad drivers, drivers with good tread, others with bald tread.
What it really boils down to is if you are looking for the "extra" margin when driving in winter conditions:
Winter Tires provide a better, safer, more stable handling driving experience than "all season" can when compared side by side. Its been proven over and over gain. If you are willing to pay the premium for this extra margin, then you have that option. I have been in enough situations to feel that for me winter tires are worth it. Others may not.
So much depends on the vehicle, how and when it is used, what kind of roads it's driven on, how well the roads are treated in your area, whether much late-night driving is required and whether you _have_ to get to work in foul weather.
Fer instance: A few years back, I bought Nokian Hakka Rsi's (forerunner of the R) for my Chevy (Malibu) Classic. I worked as a reporter for a local daily paper, part of my coverage area was in the hills of the Poconos and if news broke out up there I had to cover it, even at night. The difference in conditions between the foothills of the Poconos and near the top of the mountain---12 miles as the birds fly---can be stark.
I can't say there was a time when the Nokians clearly saved me from sliding off the road or having an accident, but they sure helped my peace of mind and confidence level---and top safe speed---as I rushed around the hills in the dark, in a rush for deadline. I considered it money well spent---and even then they were not cheap.
The next winter, I no longer worked at the paper and did not need to drive as much: certainly not as much at night or in the hills. I debated whether to put the Hakkas on again or sell them, as they still had good tread. Then a friend, who lives in the hills I mentioned, off a semi-back road, got a job in town that required her to work late and drive home uphill at night. Her boss was nice, but expected employees to show up for work as long as the place was open....plus she drove a Jetta VR6, not a great winter vehicle despite FWD and ABS. Powerful engine, tight suspension, etc.
I gave her the Nokians as a combined holiday/birthday gift. She reported the same thing I did: She did not think she ever would have literally crashed for lack of the Hakkas, but they helped a great deal---enough for an ordinary driver to notice---when the roads were slopped up and slick. Plus it eased her mind no end.
This winter I am content with my new Hankook H727s. They did great in the first two snow storms; I think TR test results and most driver reviews are correct: They are a very good winter tire, for an A/S. If I had more $$$ to spare I would have gotten winter tires, probably on their own steelies, but for now I am content.
If I get another job that requires travel w/out the option at night up in the hills, on roads that are not at the top of the priority list for plowing/treating....then I will find a way to afford snow tires again.
So, it all depends.