Originally Posted By: Kira
You should provide a year range, price range or something to help parameterize your position.
FYI: My dear mother bought a 1991 Taurus GL with 16K. It as a "Ford Program Car" (a returned fleet car).
In her case it was a Budget Rent-a-Car.
The trans began shifting weirdly around 54K. I changed the fluid and realized no improvement.
Within 2 days Ford contacted her by mail admitting to bad transmissions. Their offer was to fix/replace the unit if the car was under 60K. That would've been in 1997.
The "Ford Rebuilt" transmission (it bore a sticker attesting to its in-house rebuild) did its job for 4 years.
The replaced unit failed in exactly the same way. We sold it for $800 in 2001 and she bought a CPO Saab 9-5 SE.
The question for you is "when did Ford finally stop building deficient transmissions for that car?"
I'm a firm believer in Ford's planned tinkering with transmissions in order to make cars die earlier than necessary.
Remember, only Ford had Aisin-Warner make bad AW-55-50 transmissions. They did this to their Volvo line. The 55-50 is a solid transmission in Saabs, Vauxhalls, Toyotas, Lexus and other lines.
If nothing else, look into the Taurus Ford built after the FIVE HUNDRED was discontinued. IIRC the Taurus was absent for 2 years. The FIVE HUNDRED's CVT was trash. I read that Ford couldn't deliver replacement units fast enough for those things.
Good luck.
We just bought a 2006 Ford Five Hundred with the Aisin Warner AWF21 six speed automatic FWD. They seem to be solid but the CVT used 2005-2007 AWD got a bad name but I have no personal CVT experience. The 2008+ Taurus's got the new Ford/GM six speed I have read.
While Ford did build the 2004 Taurus for fleet sales through 2007 the 2005-2007 Five Hundred and the 2008-2009 Ford Taurus line was built to the first gen Volvo S80 chassis since Ford had purchased Volvo and wanted a new chassis for the Taurus line.
Last month we got our 2006 Ford Five Hundred SEL with 110K miles in great condition for $5K even cash at the Ford dealership. They gave the owner of the past 10 years $3K on trade for a new car.
$5K-$10K will buy a nice 2005-2009 Ford 500/Taurus on the Volvo S80 (1998-2006 generation). The 2008-2008 got the 3.5L engine vs the 3.0L. Our 3.0 had a lot of power/speed if you give it enough gas to unlock the torque converter.
Take off light on the gas and it will be in 6th gear with TC locked at 40 MPH. Yes it seems under powered in that point. This is how it can get 30 MPG. If you want to move just go to 50% throttle and it will shift to 3rd and MOVE.
The 6 speed vs the old 4 speed is awesome BUT a different driving experience.
While we only have 2500 miles put on our 1600 miles was put on it in two days and all went well with single digit temps on the MN end of of our round trip.
Without a question the 2005-2009 generation of these cars can be a good value. Personally I would stay away from the CVT transmissions. They were only in the 2005-2007 versions labeled Five Hundred on the trunk lid. The SE has cloth seats whereas the SEL and Limited came with leather the best I can tell.
Keep in mind 2005-2007 Ford Taurus fleet cars were basically the same as the 2004 old style Taurus the best I can tell but may a good option if the price is right.