My proof is logic which I will happily supply. You think the failures are occurring because of 15w? News flash. People been running a wide variety of diesel oils for decades including premium and garbage. Don't blame the oil on poor mechanical design.
Read the TSB. It blames deposits. What magical property of oil is related to carbon deposits (or preventing them) within iddy biddy lifter parts? It ain't cold flow viscosity my friend. It's chemistry. This is BITOG where we expect readers to know the difference. Ram wants you to use better chemistry, so they're nay naying the typically conventional 15w grade. (It's kinda like what Ford more elegantly did when they released the F1 spec and back-spec'd to it.)
I, on the other hand, believe that Ram has some morsel of evidence that using higher QUALITY oil, regardless of grade, provides the following two bandaids:
1) Potentially keeping things clean enough to limp the hydraulic lifters through the warranty period.
2) Potentially providing better lubrication, enough to limp the rollers and cam lobes through the warranty period, despite the rollers rolling sideways due to poorly machined alignment pin slots in the velveta cheese CGI block and poor cam/lifter metallurgy.
You see the oil as the culprit. I see the oil as the band aid...as supported by the
most recent TSB magic elixir nonsense. Bad design is the culprit. Just like the 6.4 hemi. Just like the 3.0 ecodiesel. Just like the GM 6.2. Ad nauseum.
If I was wrong, you would see higher rates of 19-24 valvetrains swarfing themselves to death in colder climates, because after all, 5w is only 10 C thinner than 15w. This is not the case. 19-24 valvetrains are failing regardless of climate. Thick oil is not the problem. If I was FCA I'd do the same thing. I'd try every cheap fix I could find to try and magically get those motors through warranty. Better oil and additives are two easy places to start.
Got some handy photos over here for you.
https://www.igotacummins.com/threads/25784-Hamilton-Cam-Flat-Tappet-Conversion/page2
Do we think 15w vs 5w caused this to happen in 58k miles?
View attachment 300149