Originally Posted by double vanos
This is a good question. I have the same maintenance item coming up shortly on my F150 and would to use a fel-pro gasket instead of the RTV the factory used. As noted RTV is messy and one could goof it up. Another disturbing aspect is that only certain RTVs should be used due to modern diff oils having additives that can dissolve the RTV sealant.
Listening to what everyone has to say....
I used the Fel-pro paper gasket on a 2011 F150 (blue colored paper). Works great - a lot easier than RTV and much quicker. And, the next time I change my differential fluid, it will be a lot easier to take off - spent all sorts of time scraping off the factory-applied RTV when I did the last fluid change.