Abuse seems the most likely answer to the thread title question.
I would agree, but what would they base that on?Abuse seems the most likely answer to the thread title question.
Not sure. Examination of the gears once opened?I would agree, but what would they base that on?
Do they even open up transmissions or engines anymore? Don't they just replace them? And once opened up, how do you tell the difference between abuse and a manufacturing defect?Not sure. Examination of the gears once opened?
Looks like Honda has Service Diagnostic Recorders.I don't know if these cars have a flash counter but the dealer should be able to find out.
Good point. I would still call and ask "I'm considering buying this car but the trans is blown up, what do you think of my chances of warranty repair are?" At least you can feel around and see if the service advisor will say anything eluding to "oh yeah we get these a lot because kids blow them up" or "there's a TSB for that".Make an appointment with service and we'll take a look at it. No dealer will give an over the phone diagnosis.
Wonder if there is a way for owners to access what is stored and how long its stored. I think VW has a similar system because so many people were blowing engines.
Looks like Honda has Service Diagnostic Recorders.
Service Diagnostic Recorders
This vehicle is equipped with service-related devices that record information about powertrain performance. The data can be used to verify emissions law requirements and/or help technicians diagnose and solve service problems. It may also be combined with data from other sources for research purposes, but it remains confidential. Some diagnostic and maintenance information is uploaded to Honda upon vehicle start up.
I guess it can store data like when the engine exceeds red line or maybe misses a shift? Wonder if there is a way for owners to access what is stored and how long its stored. I think VW has a similar system because so many people were blowing engines.
Good idea.Good point. I would still call and ask "I'm considering buying this car but the trans is blown up, what do you think of my chances of warranty repair are?"
I do have a service invoice from a Honda dealer where the customer states problems with 2nd gear. But that was 2 years and 14,000 miles ago. Tech says it needs a clutch for $2700 and a transmission for $13,200. There was no charge on the invoice.Could also be that the previous owner attempted a warranty repair and was denied, this information can be helpful.
Yes they're waer items but there's still a point where an automaker can claim excessive wear/abuse. I don't know what that is with Honda. BMW clutches don't die at 44k miles. I'm just shotgunning potential reasons for denying a claim over a known issue.Clutches are wear items like brake pads. That's why there is no warranty on them. A clutch wearing out at 44,000 miles on a high performance car isn't unusual nor indicative of abuse. And how would they even know it was replaced?
That’s your answer. If another dealer was unwilling to warranty the transmission 2 years ago, they definitely won’t warranty it now. That info will be in their centralized system. Though, it’s pretty slow right now, so…Good idea.
I do have a service invoice from a Honda dealer where the customer states problems with 2nd gear. But that was 2 years and 14,000 miles ago. Tech says it needs a clutch for $2700 and a transmission for $13,200. There was no charge on the invoice.
All service history is centralized for Honda. Create a Honda owners account and you’ll be able to see it.Well, I obviously wouldn't take it to that same dealer. Unless there was a warranty repair, I'm not sure that info leaves that dealer. Will have to find out.
He’s too busy with the Lesbaru.So what's the conclusion here??
Is ALL work recorded or just warranty-related work ? I think with other automakers, they only share warranty work, recalls, etc.All service history is centralized for Honda.