5w30 in Skyactiv

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Gokhan
Originally Posted by sjd
Once again, the Mexican 5W30 and Mexican OCI have NOTHING to do with anything other than being in my owner's manual so please quit it with that straw man. I am well aware that my manual only mentioned 5W30 for Mexico.

It is possible that the manuals in Europe and Japan do mention 0W20, but as you point out, 5W30 is "allowed" so how is it wrong to use synthetic 5W30 when the 2.0 engine is the EXACT same everywhere in the world? I understand about the potential warranty implications.

I'm looking for better protection from heat during autocross and track use and I'm looking for a low SAPS oil to help with intake valve deposits. I don't know that I can find that in a 0W20. If you have scientific reasoning behind why I should run 0W20 over a 5W30 I'd like to hear it.

I have never said that you should use 0W-20 or you can't use 5w30.

You were saying that Mazda recommended 5w30 everywhere else in the world, and I corrected that as (1) the synthetic ILSAC GF-5 0W-20 being the "recommended" grade everywhere else in the world and (2) synthetic ACEA A5/B5 5w30 being an "alternative" grade everywhere else in the world. For more details see the pages from the global owner's manual I posted earlier that gives customized oil recommendations for every country in the world, according to oil and spec availability in different countries.

As a general rule, you can always safely go somewhat higher in viscosity than the recommended, and this may beneficial for high-speed driving or extreme loads as Toyota puts it in every owner's manual.

For track use, a GM dexos1 5w30 oil or even an ACEA C3 0W-30/5w30 and/or VW 504.00/Porsche C30 oil, which is even thicker, is probably a better choice. For regular driving I would use a 0W-20 because of its higher base-oil quality, lower VII content, and higher fuel efficiency than a 5w30's. Unlike a 5w30 you need the best base stocks to make a 0W-20. For example ACEA 0W-20 oils (C5 and C6 categories) have the strictest specs among all ACEA oils. Therefore, for normal driving 0W-20 should be the best, but for aggressive driving a thicker oil may be better.

w20 even in very hot climate?
for dd driving
 
the 0w30 has higher base-oil quality and lower VII content like the the 0w20 compared to the 5w30 right?
its in the 0w?
 
Originally Posted by edyvw
Both ILSAC GF5 0W20 and 5W30 are recommended. 5W30 ILSAC GF-5 is NOT alternative oil like for example 10W40 is.
Other oils are alternatives for Skyactive.

OK, 0W-20 is the recommended and 5w30 is the alternative oil in Japan. Both 0W-20 and 5w30 are recommended oils in Europe and Taiwan. For the new Skyactive-X engine, 0W-20 is the recommended oil and 5w30 is the alternative oil.

https://www.bobistheoilguy.com/foru...il-and-filter-brand-and-type#Post5379123
https://www.mazda.co.jp/globalassets/assets/carlife/manual/common/onlinemanual/cx-5_201912.pdf
 
Originally Posted by avi1777
w20 even in very hot climate?
for dd driving

Global manual I linked above doesn't make a distinction based on climate. Arabic Peninsula and African countries included in the manual all list 0W-20 among the recommended grades.

I don't know what dd driving is, but for aggressive driving, a thicker oil may be better suited.
 
Originally Posted by avi1777
the 0w30 has higher base-oil quality and lower VII content like the the 0w20 compared to the 5w30 right?
its in the 0w?

Yes, a 0W-30 would have a high-quality base oil. However, a 0W-30 would have more VII than a 0W-20 in order to thicken the base oil more.

The base-oil quality must increase when the CCS (cold-cranking simulator) spec gets stricter. For this reason a GM dexos1 or ACEA C5 0W-20 requires Group III+, GTL, or PAO. It is not possible to make such a 0W-20 with Group III. You need at least Group III+. In contrast a GM dexos1 or ACEA A5/B5 5w30 can be made with cheap, low-quality Group III base stocks (for example Castrol Edge 5w30 dexos1, store-brand 5w30 dexos1 oils, etc.). I posted a very nice article that explains this here:

The synthetics are coming: Base-oil quality index (BOQI) revisited

"A good portion of the market also complies with General Motors Dexos1 specification, which requires 13 percent volatility or lower. Its possible to formulate an SAE 0W-20 API SP oil with standard API Group III base oil, but to make a Dexos-approved product, the formulation must include Group III+ in significant amounts, or even some Group IV, he said."
 
so the 20w is better against deposits,fuel consumption and longer oci's but it is better against wear and protecting the engine in hot climate?
many wrenglers in hot climate over in texas that do extensive rock crawling and off roading where the engine gets really hot uses 20w so i guess its ok but is it better or as good as a 30w?
is the base oil is the key for protecting the engine or is it the "right" grade?
 
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.
 
Originally Posted by avi1777

w20 even in very hot climate?
for dd driving

Engines generally operate at the same temperature regardless of climate, engine operating temperature is pretty much set by the engine coolant temperature which is mostly dictated by what thermostat is used.
 
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.





So was there a question in this thread? It seems your mind is made up already. Good luck
 
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.


You need to school dad that yesterday's choice oils aren't the best for today's modern engines.
 
Originally Posted by Triple_Se7en
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.


You need to school dad that yesterday's choice oils aren't the best for today's modern engines.


haha I'm trying trust me!
 
Originally Posted by Triple_Se7en
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.
You need to school dad that yesterday's choice oils aren't the best for today's modern engines.

The Castrol Edge is API SN PLUS, how is that "yesterday's choice"? Mazda doesn't even give a required API license, do they?
 
Originally Posted by Triple_Se7en
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.


You need to school dad that yesterday's choice oils aren't the best for today's modern engines.

Or maybe just leave him alone and let him run what he wants in his car. Castrol Edge isn't exactly junk.
 
Originally Posted by Triple_Se7en
Originally Posted by wolf_06
My father is checking out a 2020 Mazda 6, and I know for sure he will run a 5w30 castrol Edge in it regardless if it calls for 0w20 haha, he used castrol in all his machinery all his live, big user of castrol GTX 5w30 and strait w30 castrol oil for small engines. I told him new cars now uses 0w20 up to 16,000 km OCI and he looked at me with a wierd face.


You need to school dad that yesterday's choice oils aren't the best for today's modern engines.

0W20 is not particularly first choice of vehicle manufacturers too. It is CAFE driven. Many of these engines that run in the US on 0W20, run on other markets with much better fuel quality on thicker oils. Difference? The way emissions are regulated.
 
20w in cold canada is perfect and u can put just about anything in a mazda and it will be fine.
didnt get the edge being yesterday choice as well,its a superb oil.
 
Originally Posted by avi1777
20w in cold canada is perfect and u can put just about anything in a mazda and it will be fine.
didnt get the edge being yesterday choice as well,its a superb oil.

There's been all kind of mention here at Bitog, that Castrol's base oils are far-from-superb. But if you desire the brand name, then that's your decision.
I do like Castrol's add-packs in SN Plus. They made big changes to Dexos add-pack formulas, so I bought an Edge jug to use. When I replaced it with Valvoline Advanced, I immediately knew Advanced serves Dexos GDI-engines better.

My engines used to be loaded with varnish throughout. the 90s. That's when I used Castrol. A superb oil?...... I keep trying it every once in a while. But I never buy two OCIs of Castrol in a row.
 
Originally Posted by avi1777
u r talking 30 years ago man a lot has changed since

I'm not pointing out BITOG posts from 30 years ago (don't exist)..... not 15 - 10 or 5 either.
BTW....Where are all your posts in support of Castrol Edge?

Please don't waffle here. Ex: You claim nice quietness / speaking highly of Motul - then say you'll rather use Mobil-1, which many here at BITOG claim to be a loud engine oil.
So which side of the fence are you standing on?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom