2eha and toyota

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: Deontologist
The 2-EHA controversy seemed to have started with a few lawyers representing clients who claimed their cars were damaged by DexCool. And as we all know, lawyers tend to stretch the truth sometimes.


No truth was stretched. It was a frigging fact. I know this first hand because of two lower intake leaks because Dexcool ate the [censored] plastic gaskets that GM was using. GM settled the lawsuit, and that is fact too. My coolant system was a wreck.

Plenty of pictures of Dexcool sludge on the net. Engine designs and gaskets are more compatible with Dexcool today, but there is no way in h.e.l.l I would put any Dexclone in an older car.
 
Originally Posted By: Deontologist


I think I might flush it out with Zerex in the next few weeks just for some peace of mind. Just wish that there was a definitive answer. Is there a Toyota or Honda rep on the forums somewhere?


Why are you putting your mind into needless storm and confusion.
Does the manual say other coolants can be used - NO. Atleast that is what I have in Japanese autos..
Pay the additional cost and put OEM fluid.
 
Originally Posted By: MaximaGuy

Does the manual say other coolants can be used - NO. Atleast that is what I have in Japanese autos..
Pay the additional cost and put OEM fluid.


Well the owners' manual, and the shop manual, both of which I've looked at several times, say to use a "high-quality" ethylene-glycol based coolant with some other conditions attached. Nowhere did it mention anything about DexCool, 2-EHA, etc. Super Tech AM/AM seemed to fit the bill, and I stupidly tried to save 3 dollars by going with ST.

Even if ST works PERFECTLY, it still cost me my peace of mind. And that's worth more than 3 bucks. Don't be like me, to everyone who is reading this in the future.

Right now, for peace of mind, I could use these things:

1) A Toyota or Honda rep explaining in detail the whole situation about 2-EHA in their engines. I still don't conclusively know whether it's prohibited or not, because the manuals don't mention anything about 2-EHA or Dexcool or whatever.

2) A full system flush and replacement with Zerex Asian.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: Oro_O
Originally Posted By: Deontologist
Well I've decided now after reading that guy's horror stories to purchase 5 bottles of Zerex Asian and am currently completing a coolant flush of both cars.


Personally I think that sounds wise. But maybe hold on about how to do the flush a minute, sounds like you bought too much.

We got a Lexus a few years ago that had green in it. I converted it to Red. I studied this and computed concentrations down to the ounce and this is what worked best for me based on science, math, and economics:

a) open radiator tap, and both of the block drain plugs (on a V).
b) refill with $.89/gallon distilled water from your supermarket. To full.
c) run until hot and t-stat opens and mixes with heater.
d) let cool, then dump it per a)
e) repeat b-d)
f) You should NOW be down to having only 2 ounces of the old in your system, and it cost you $5 of distilled water. Good enough. If you wanna get manic, add some citric acid and really clean things in this process. Cheap and super effective. Google it.
g) Now that you are clean, add 60% of this (see link below) to your system total volume. Average system volume on a V6 is 9.7 qts, so that is 5.9 qts. Check what it is for yours. So two of these containers delivered to your door for $25. Then top up with dH2O. You add the concetrate in first to compensate for the fact there is 1.5 to 2 quarts of pure water in your heater core you can't drain out.

This is the stuff to buy:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/OEM-Concentrate-...M-/161475752394

h) you are now at 60% af/dH20 mix, which maximizes your position on the eutectic graph of bp/elevation-fp/depression. So you are protected down to like -60F and not the marginal -30F 50/50 gives and isnt' adequate in the severe northern US tier or Canada. and you have more anti-corrosion and other additives.

And, with the two quarts left over from what you bought, you can also do your 1st drain/fill in 30k miles. Also, with 2 qts of water in your heater core, you can't get anywhere near 50/50 if you use pre-mix. So check the eutectic graph of running 40/60, etc. and decide if you are happy. I would not be.

So take the $50 bucks of diluted Zerex back and do the job right! For less, too.

BTW, the Lexus I converted from green to red, the radiator rotted out 50k later; the plastic/polymer upper reservoir was so weakened from heat and the chemical it did not like, the upper radiator inlet pipe just collapsed.

Previously, a Lexus GS we had did the same with the heater valve; it just disintegrated after being run with non Asian coolant for a while. I understand in the past when you had to pay $30/gallon for concentrate, some people would cheap out and run non-Asian coolant. They won't fail right away, but eventually they will. Now that there are uber cheap and available compatible fluids, it's stupid to run something else.

DexCool might work. BUT - dexcool is more sensitive to oxidation and the expansion tanks on GM vehicles (my parents have two I service) are different than the fully vented expansion tanks on ToyoLex vehicles. I would not run dexcool in a more permissively ventilated Toyota coolant system.

In my parents' GM cars, I check the expansion tank and hoses annually (they are both now 10 years old) to ward this off. There are plenty of horror stories of older GM vehicles where the system wearks, lets in air, and the coolant goes to [censored] in a handbasket. I think dexcool is fine you are under warranty, but it isn't friendly as it ages and systems wear. It's a "just get it out of warranty" kinda product. Just like Toyota WS transmission fluid - might get you to 100k miles and out of warranty (often does not), but it's not a long term fluid like they advertise. -So I'm not picking on GM. toyota and everyone cheaps the [censored] out wherever they can and screws the 2nd or long-term original owner. None of these guys have the long-term owner or 2nd buyer's interest at heart.

Don't screw around. Flush the system twice at least, three is better. Then put it 60/40 with Asian red or pink fluid. Then drain/fill the rad. every 30k. It then might last a half million miles or more.



Thank you for the detailed instructions. So far I've just been opening the lower radiator stopcock. I can't seem to find the drain plugs on the engine block, even after looking at the shop service manual. I've decided to just take ~1 gallon as the amount of water/old coolant left in the block, and I'm planning on buying some full-strength Pentofrost A1 to pour straight into the block to get a ~50/50 mix. Then I'll top off with Zerex Asian. I'll return any unused Zerex later, or just keep it in case my hoses and head gasket have been ruined by Dexcool and I need to keep topping off the [censored] coolant.
 
Find the right match for your vehicle. http://www.oemantifreeze.com/

OEM Pink by Reochem. Can wait to buy it when they have free shipping. It's been as low as $9.99 shipped free. Concentrate so it makes two gallons.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/OEM-Concentrate-Extended-Life-Radiator-Antifreeze-Coolant-Pink-86-174POEM/152426586291?_trkparms=aid%3D222007%26algo%3DSIM.MBE%26ao%3D2%26asc%3D41375%26meid%3Dd8804a9d4e7645dd9f1991124b8c70ec%26pid%3D100005%26rk%3D1%26rkt%3D6%26sd%3D161475752394&_trksid=p2047675.c100005.m1851

OEM Red by Reochem same as above except it's for older Toyota.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/OEM-Concentrate-extended-life-Red-radiator-antifreeze-coolant-86-374ROEM/161475752394?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649
 
What's going on here? On one of my Toyotas, I put in a LOT of the Super Tech AM/AM green-colored coolant. The radiator cap was literally sitting in that green-coolant for the last few months. And it seems that the plastic "head" of the cap has dissolved, unlike on my other Toyota, where the radiator cap wasn't quite immersed in the coolant. In fact, the Toyota with the intact radiator cap is a 1999 model, while the one with the partially dissolved cap is a 2006!

Could this be a sign that the AM/AM coolant has harmed my car? Or is this harmless?

Pictures of dissolved (?) cap

http://imgur.com/a/FE7ds
 
Originally Posted By: Deontologist
What's going on here? On one of my Toyotas, I put in a LOT of the Super Tech AM/AM green-colored coolant. The radiator cap was literally sitting in that green-coolant for the last few months. And it seems that the plastic "head" of the cap has dissolved, unlike on my other Toyota, where the radiator cap wasn't quite immersed in the coolant. In fact, the Toyota with the intact radiator cap is a 1999 model, while the one with the partially dissolved cap is a 2006!

Could this be a sign that the AM/AM coolant has harmed my car? Or is this harmless?


Sad to her your situation- time to recollect the fallout from coolant shortcuts.
 
Originally Posted By: Deontologist
What's going on here? On one of my Toyotas, I put in a LOT of the Super Tech AM/AM green-colored coolant. The radiator cap was literally sitting in that green-coolant for the last few months. And it seems that the plastic "head" of the cap has dissolved, unlike on my other Toyota, where the radiator cap wasn't quite immersed in the coolant. In fact, the Toyota with the intact radiator cap is a 1999 model, while the one with the partially dissolved cap is a 2006!

Could this be a sign that the AM/AM coolant has harmed my car? Or is this harmless?

Pictures of dissolved (?) cap

http://imgur.com/a/FE7ds


I had a Toyota/Lexus cap that the rubber gasket was dissolving - not exactly like yours. We bought the Lexus used and it came with some unknown green in it. I flushed it out fully with many cycles of dH2O and refilled with toyota red and a new cap. The radiator lasted ~4 years more and then the radiator inlet pipe softened and cracked. It also had corrosion going on at the seam all along the tank/body interface, too (where the upper composite tank joins the aluminum tube/fin body). Fortunately, Denso radiators are surprisingly cheap.

I had a friend with a Lexus GS that came with an unknown green in it. The heater valve softened and corroded shortly after he got it, similar to my radiator inlet pipe. These parts should not have failed at the time/miles they did and the only commonality was a non-Toyota (albeit unknown in each case) coolant in it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top