Recent Topics
cheap upgrade to win 10 from win 7 s/n
by bmwjohn
08/24/16 04:25 PM
trimmer loses power when hot
by motor_oil_madman
08/24/16 04:21 PM
NAPA "GOLD" #1358, 10,080 miles CUT OPEN
by car51
08/24/16 04:01 PM
2016 F-350 diesel factory filter CUT OPEN
by car51
08/24/16 03:37 PM
Craftsman Four Stroke Weed Whacker
by yeehaw1960
08/24/16 03:30 PM
Heat Pump ?'s
by metalone
08/24/16 03:12 PM
Career change advice
by ram_man
08/24/16 02:55 PM
Petro-Canada Motor Oils
by motoroilman
08/24/16 02:45 PM
Cyclists
by Whitewolf
08/24/16 02:19 PM
Wife is livid
by Jarlaxle
08/24/16 01:42 PM
Thoughts on the Honda mowers?
by glock19
08/24/16 01:26 PM
5W30 In a HM Oil Engine
by BlueOvalFitter
08/24/16 01:21 PM
Newest Members
dan0928, basher, Bandita, DaveyJones, OldEuroCarLover
58904 Registered Users
Who's Online
91 registered (440Magnum, 1JZ_E46, 2015_PSD, 09_GXP, Al, 2002 Maxima SE, 11 invisible), 1604 Guests and 8 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
58904 Members
66 Forums
253501 Topics
4161227 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG
Topic Options
#1405439 - 03/16/09 09:35 PM 5w30 vs 10w30
05Blazer Offline


Registered: 12/04/08
Posts: 348
Loc: Illinois
I have switched my young 4.3L Blazer that sees fleet use to Maxlife Blend and have been very happy with the quietness of the engine and slowing of the cooler line leaks. I have always used 5w30 as per the owners manual & I am about to do an oil change for the summer and am wondering if I will see any benefit by switching to 10w30. After looking at the product specs on Valvoline's website they seem to have near matching numbers in every category except the 5W30 has a higher Viscosity Index rating of 163 vs. 10W30 146. This leads me to believe that the 5W30 might actually even be better period. Your thoughts?

thanks
_________________________
12 GMC Yukon SLT 4WD 5.3L 8K
Mobil1 EP 5W30 AC DELCO PF48
11 Honda Pilot EX 4WD 3.5L 20k
Penn Plat 0W20 OEM filter

Top
#1405458 - 03/16/09 09:52 PM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: 05Blazer]
wannafbody Offline


Registered: 01/02/08
Posts: 895
Loc: PA
Theoretically the 5w should be better than a 10w at startup.
_________________________
2000 TA WS6

Top
#1405508 - 03/16/09 10:46 PM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: wannafbody]
FrankN4 Offline


Registered: 04/18/08
Posts: 1093
Loc: Kentucky
You can only compare the VI of the same grade, XW-X to XW-X. You could not compare the VI of a 5W-30 to a 10W-30.

Check out this thread:
http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=1399421&fpart=1
_________________________
Actually, I never was as good as I used to be.

Top
#1405515 - 03/16/09 10:56 PM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: wannafbody]
TallPaul Offline


Registered: 10/22/03
Posts: 13091
Loc: By Detroit
Viscosity index is meaningless unless you know the base oil and amount of viscosity index improver (VII) in the oil. An oil could have a very high VII and low grade base oil if enough VII is added, but would not necessarily be better than say a straight 30 which has no VII and a much lower viscosity index.

All else equal, there would be less VII in the 10w30, but many times all else is not equal. Two oils of the same brand may have some measure of better quality base oil in the 5w30 to make up for the wider spread, that is, so much Group III could be added to the 5w30 so the VII would not have to be boosted as much.

But I would run the 10w30 in summer since you don't need extreme cold starting properties.

Top
#1405531 - 03/16/09 11:14 PM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: TallPaul]
Peter_Pan Offline


Registered: 07/07/08
Posts: 175
Loc: CA
One thing I've noticed consistantly when reading the data sheets for oils is that 10W-30 has a lower NOACK and higher density compared to 5W-30 which is expected more or less due to the differing amounts of VII added and his translates in to a more stable oil IMO. All said and done though, the difference is very small and you may not even feel a difference at all.

I agree with Paul, 10W-30 is a very good choice whenever temperatures are above 20-30 F.
_________________________
08 Merc E350 4MATIC 3.5 M272
07 Mercedes Benz C280 4MATIC 3.0 M272
09 Craftsman YTS4500 0.750 B&S V-Twin 24HP XRD

Top
#1405680 - 03/17/09 07:36 AM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: Peter_Pan]
Nickdfresh Offline


Registered: 03/15/06
Posts: 4249
Loc: Buffalo, NY
Both 5W-30 and 10W-30 MaxLife have a -42F pour point, so I doubt you'll notice much difference even in cold weather at start-up...

I would use the 10W-30 if doing a lot of highway driving since it will not sheer as much. Although, the 5W-30 ML is pretty "thick" at temperature so sheering is probably irrelevant...

Top
#1405693 - 03/17/09 07:55 AM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: Nickdfresh]
TallPaul Offline


Registered: 10/22/03
Posts: 13091
Loc: By Detroit
Yes Peter Pan, NOACK is an excellent parameter to compare oils on.

I should clarify, viscosity index (VI) is largely based on the inherent VI of the base oil and the amount (and type) of viscosity index improver added (VII). So you never know how much of the VI is due to the quality of the base oil vs loads of VII being added. That's why I totally ignore VI as a parameter for evaluating/comparing oils.

Top
#1405694 - 03/17/09 07:58 AM Re: 5w30 vs 10w30 [Re: TallPaul]
addyguy Offline


Registered: 09/08/05
Posts: 13972
Loc: Canada
I'd run the 10W-30 during the summer. A touch thicker at lower temps, and may burn/leak a bit less.
_________________________
2010 Kia Soul 2U - 2.0L I-4, auto, 89k miles.
MM Supreme 5W-30; QS 14612 filter.

Top