Originally Posted By: Le_bow_ski
If you really have the miata HLA tick, and many if not most have it to one degree or another, what seems to work for most folks is a high detergent oil like Rotella T6 5W-40. The reason is a high detergent oil will help clean out the tiny orifices in the lifters, making it easier for them to fill while the engine is running. Short ocis also seem to help during the cleaning process. I used 5k mile oci. Worked for me.
After five or six sessions with T6 I switched to Mobil1 0W-40 and the motor remains quiet. No offense, but I wouldn't use conventional, nor would I use a 10W-30. The goal is good cleaning and good flow quickly. A conventional 10W-30 isn't optimum for meeting those goals.
If your pistons are kissing carbon on the heads, that's an entirely different animal, but I doubt that's the case. Btw, what year is the car?
Agreed, it's most likely NOT a piston-carbon issue. This is such a common complaint of 99% of all Miatas with HLA adjusters.
I've pretty much decided that the ticking starts to happen approximately 3k after the initial oil change - no matter what oil I choose. Thicker grades often solve the "hot tick" issue while 0w-5w-xx oils flow better and solve the cold ticks.
Many owners on the Miata forum experiment with different grades
until they find results for their cars. I've heard good things about Rotella 5w-40. I personally have tried over a 1/2 dozen oils in my car and found success with Chevron 5w-30 conventional in the cooler months. With over 200k on mine, it seems to like 10w-40 in the hot summer months.