There is a large amount of evidence (all the UOAs here and other sites) that show dino HDEOs can perform completely in step with high-end PAO products, and provide the same wear protetion, when "used as directed".
The UOA copied above is mine. Look it over. Tell me how much "better" you think a PAO would have done? Better yet, show me UOAs that exhibit success where ONLY the PAO would have survived, and a dino failed.
Under certain condition (I am being specific here), dino's are every bit as good as PAOs.
1) as long as OCIs are short to moderate (less than 10k miles)
2) as long as temps are not obscenely extreme (stay between -10 deg F and not "water pump failure" hot)
BTW - in case you didn't catch my post in another thread, I personally don't believe that any "pure PAO" can exist in the mass market. High end products such as Delvac 1 has some small amount of lesser groups added to them to assist in the lubricant holding it's add-pack in suspension. There is no "pure" lube on the mass market.