My solution to the temporary spare doesn't cost me any extra, as I keep two sets of tires for each vehicle - all season tires for summer, and the winter tires.
For my car, this actually works very well. The spare tire well was actually designed to accommodate a full size spare, as the first model year came with them, before they got downgraded to temporary spares for the subsequent years. I simply have one of my summer tires in the spare well over the winter, and one of my winter tires in there over the summer.
Of course, this won't work for every vehicle, like my van. The underbody stowage space is only big enough for the temporary spare. One time, the van had a flat overnight in the driveway. This was easy, as I put on a tire from the other set in the garage. The next time the van had a flat, it was while out doing errands - of course on a colder winter day. Had to get the donut on instead of a full size, but also had to get air into the donut first, as it is in an inaccessible location to check pressure regularly.
On my 2002 Protege when I had it, I would sub in the full size spare if doing a road trip (it was slightly too big for the spare well, so the board and carpet didn't sit flush to the floor). If just staying in town, then the temporary spare stayed in the spare well.
For my car, this actually works very well. The spare tire well was actually designed to accommodate a full size spare, as the first model year came with them, before they got downgraded to temporary spares for the subsequent years. I simply have one of my summer tires in the spare well over the winter, and one of my winter tires in there over the summer.
Of course, this won't work for every vehicle, like my van. The underbody stowage space is only big enough for the temporary spare. One time, the van had a flat overnight in the driveway. This was easy, as I put on a tire from the other set in the garage. The next time the van had a flat, it was while out doing errands - of course on a colder winter day. Had to get the donut on instead of a full size, but also had to get air into the donut first, as it is in an inaccessible location to check pressure regularly.
On my 2002 Protege when I had it, I would sub in the full size spare if doing a road trip (it was slightly too big for the spare well, so the board and carpet didn't sit flush to the floor). If just staying in town, then the temporary spare stayed in the spare well.