Originally Posted By: bullwinkle
Originally Posted By: demarpaint
Originally Posted By: bullwinkle
Originally Posted By: demarpaint
Where did it leak from? A loose fill cap or a seal? If it leaking from seal I wouldn't trust the jack by just topping it up, I'd repair it properly or get it repaired. Bad things can happen when jack fails.
That is what jack stands are for! It does sound like it's low on hydraulic fluid, generally the seals will leak a little, I have an older HF orange one that needs a shot occasionally.
I know what jack stands are for, and use them. Even with them a jack with a leak is unsafe. A leaking jack can fail while you're trying to place a jack stand under the vehicle, not good. I wouldn't trust it until I really checked it over! Opinions vary.
Honestly, if it falls that fast, you'll know before you even try. With as cheap as the HF ones are getting, might be time for a new one (like this one)-
https://www.harborfreight.com/3-ton-steel-heavy-duty-floor-jack-with-rapid-pump-68048.html
This jack actually can lift either back end of my F-450 when it's fully loaded, truck weighs in the neighborhood of 12K!
I have the 4 ton HF version [a nice jack, very heavy], and a 35 year old Craftsman jack that hasn't needed a top up yet. The reason for my comments here are these. A few years back my wife got a flat with our Aerostar. I had a small 3 ton floor jack in it. I drove there with with a jack stand ready to change the tire for her. I loosened the lugs, jacked it up, went to my van to get the jack stand out, as I was getting ready to slip it under, the Aerostar started coming down. I was lucky, for a few reasons. I didn't get the stand under the Aerostar, I had left the wheel on it with the lugs loose. I went back home and got the 35 year old Craftsman jack and finished the job. Long story short, I was telling the OP to check the jack over real well. If all it needs is a top up and bleed fine, if it has a leak I wouldn't trust it. I've seen them fail as you stated, they lift the car and it comes back down, that wasn't the case here. FTR this jack was full the fill cap tight, it was used a few times too w/o issue as well. I tossed it.