Felpro makes a decent gasket last I knew. I'd wire wheel the cover and scrape the diff clean. Then, I'd use a bead of Permatex Aviation Forma-Gasket #2 spread out on the cover. when it skins over, I press the gasket into place on the cvr. if you grease the face, then the gasket will stick on the cvr so you won't waste the gasket. I'm sure the the one time use RTV works great, I just prefer gaskets