Supercharger - Worth It?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
Originally Posted By: Shannow
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
When gas goes back over $5 will the 1-2 MPG make a difference?

If you buy the souped up version, can you afford an additional $1k part replacement?

Those are the questions Id be asking.


Which $1k is that ?

15mm spanner to flip the blower belt off bypasses the blower should you need to (and it's bypassed anyway at part throttle).

Biggest problem that I have with the L67 is the special accessory belt and pulley that the regular V-6 doesn't have.

Bottom end is shot peened and bullet proof


Lol just what I'd want, a car with a ghetto "bypass" because something failed.

Engine and trans are likely within statistical limits for potential for failure.

You just bought a supercharged car at a premium potentially for the supercharger... It's one more part to break no matter how you look at it.

It may well be super reliable, but the potential still exists, and in used cars, more stuff must be considered in the lifecycle cost.


In the real world, it's just not an issue. Mileage is a wash, the blower is absolutely bulletproof unless you swap pulleys & crank the boost. The transaxle is, if anything, MORE durable. (And note: regular or HD, a rebuilt 4T65E is the same price.) The only downside to the blower engine is premium fuel.
 
Originally Posted By: Jarlaxle
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
Originally Posted By: Shannow
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
When gas goes back over $5 will the 1-2 MPG make a difference?

If you buy the souped up version, can you afford an additional $1k part replacement?

Those are the questions Id be asking.


Which $1k is that ?

15mm spanner to flip the blower belt off bypasses the blower should you need to (and it's bypassed anyway at part throttle).

Biggest problem that I have with the L67 is the special accessory belt and pulley that the regular V-6 doesn't have.

Bottom end is shot peened and bullet proof


Lol just what I'd want, a car with a ghetto "bypass" because something failed.

Engine and trans are likely within statistical limits for potential for failure.

You just bought a supercharged car at a premium potentially for the supercharger... It's one more part to break no matter how you look at it.

It may well be super reliable, but the potential still exists, and in used cars, more stuff must be considered in the lifecycle cost.


In the real world, it's just not an issue. Mileage is a wash, the blower is absolutely bulletproof unless you swap pulleys & crank the boost. The transaxle is, if anything, MORE durable. (And note: regular or HD, a rebuilt 4T65E is the same price.) The only downside to the blower engine is premium fuel.

Exactly, and can tell you from two different cars both with upgraded pulleys...they blowers just don't have a problem.
 
Originally Posted By: Ram01
I just traded in a 04 gp gtp with 125k the car ran great until the abs module went and they wanted $1500 to fix. I purchase a 2013 Chevy. Malibu 2LT I like the fuel savings but miss the gp power


you can drive the car just fine without the ABS module working.
 
AT least around here, that will make it fail inspection.
frown.gif
 
Just got back from 6.5 hours of driving around the Inland Empire looking at Grand Prix(s). Saw five and test drove four of them: two NA and two supercharged. All I have to say about the supercharged engine is

HOLY COW! (Thought that was the best I could do without being censored.)

I didn't realize what an extra 60 hp could do, but I guess when you put it in the perspective of 30% more horsepower than NA, it makes sense. After driving one with a SC, there is no way I can settle with the NA version, premium gas and slightly lower fuel economy be [censored]! My 2008 Impala felt like a peddle car afterwards.

I think I have found "the one": 2006 Pontiac Grand Prix GT Supercharged

Love the color, it's only a 2006, it has a leather interior (black, which is problematic as I easily overheat, particularly when sitting on leather), 6-disc CD changer, and moonroof. The only problems are that the ABS and TC warning lights are on, there appears to be a slight oil leak from the valve covers (easy fix and will give me a chance to check for sludge/buildup), and the suspension felt a bit "clunky" when making a right hand turn out of a parking lot. We tried to take it to a mechanic today to do a basic inspection and have it checked out for the warning lights, but they said they had not idea what the lights were for and I skipped on having them check the whole thing over as I don't think I would trust that shop as far as I could throw it.

The owner is taking it to another mechanic tomorrow and will give me a call afterwards. I'm not too concerned about the ABS/TC as neither are really necessary here (although things may get a bit squirrelly pulling away from lights or getting on the freeway as the tires broke loose a bit when mashing the peddle on the one with functioning TC) and is a negotiating point in my favor. Thinking if I can get him down to $4,750 or even $5,000 I am getting a good deal as the KBB for private party is $6,999 Excellent, $6,624 Very Good, $6,399 Good, and $5,424 Fair.

My other option is 2004 Pontiac Grand Prix GTP. Color not as good (but still doable; not red, white, or black), cloth interior (no complaints there), single disc CD, and moonroof, but obvious leaks from the valve covers, needs two new front tires, don't like the wheels as much, and will need front brake pads soon. If the 2006 above does not work out, I will have this one checked by a mechanic and try to negotiate down to $5,500: they have had it on the lot since mid-November, the KBB private party values are $6,116/$5,791/$5,591/$4,741, and I would have to put $600+ into the car to make it worth $6,000.

And to address some concerns mentioned by others:

Originally Posted By: jsnyder49090
the lower intakes leak often as does valve covers the coolant elbows also.The blowers are solid the couplers sometimes make noise but is not that hard to repair a 20.00 part.The transmissions are problematic with higher miles they tend to shift hard when hot but they make a kit to fix and can be installed pretty easily.Look for these issues and service the trans should be good for atleast another 100,000

From what I've read, the LIM are not a problem after 2003, blowers sounded fine, and both shifted like champs (better than the NA models I tested).

Originally Posted By: JHZR2
When gas goes back over $5 will the 1-2 MPG make a difference?

If you buy the souped up version, can you afford an additional $1k part replacement?

Those are the questions Id be asking.

Not worried on either account as I can always bypass SC like Shannow said.

Originally Posted By: KD0AXS
Who drives "reasonably" in a supercharged car?
laugh.gif


I didn't think this would be a problem with me, but after test driving two, I am having second thoughts!
grin.gif


Originally Posted By: Trav
What really helps this car is Bilstein struts and GM performance chassis upgrades.
Tubular rear trailing arms, strut connectors, performance sway bars front and rear really help in handling.
I put later model impala front rotors 12" up front with Camero front twin piston calipers,
SS lines, its a huge improvement.

I'm happy with the handling but may have to do some brake upgrades as the braking performance is worse than the Burb!

Originally Posted By: supton
I'm not sure I'd buy anything used unless if I had a couple grand sitting around "just in case". Even if it checks out great, it's still used, and, stuff can and does just break. Out of the blue. That couple grand is your "warrenty" that pays for it.

Will still have $16k+ in the bank after purchase price, tax, and registration. (And no, I will not consider purchasing new to take advantage of the warranty as I do not want to be saddled with the depreciation drop, especially because I may be offered a company car again after a year.)

Originally Posted By: Jarlaxle
(In reference to no ABS/TC) AT least around here, that will make it fail inspection.
frown.gif


Surprisingly, no safety inspection in the People's Republic of California.
 
My aunt has a '99 or '00 Regal with the supercharged 3800 Series II. I'm not sure how much it has in common with the later model SC'd 3.8s, but the engine has never given her one bit of trouble, despite the rest of the car literally falling to pieces around it. Keep in mind she drives like Dale Earnhardt and isn't the best person for keeping up maintenance.
 
Originally Posted By: MinamiKotaro
Keep in mind she drives like Dale Earnhardt and isn't the best person for keeping up maintenance.

Sound's like my wife! Still trying to get her to lay off the gas pedal and I may have to put the GP into a living trust and write PM instructions into my will in case I kick the bucket before her!
 
I'd go for the '06. Chances are the ABS/TC issue is a wheel speed sensor that's integrated into the hub. That's a fairly easy fix if so. Make sure to get a name brand hub, or be prepared to do the job over and over again as the cheap ones fail repeatedly.
 
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
Engine and trans are likely within statistical limits for potential for failure.

The transmission yes but a good HD rebuild from triple edge takes care of that.
The engine isn't even close. I know a 16 PSI turbo doesn't bother the stock bottom end in a 3800 GT making a lot more HP than the stock GTP. The 3800 is almost bulletproof.
 
Originally Posted By: sciphi
I'd go for the '06. Chances are the ABS/TC issue is a wheel speed sensor that's integrated into the hub. That's a fairly easy fix if so. Make sure to get a name brand hub, or be prepared to do the job over and over again as the cheap ones fail repeatedly.


+2 on this and probably a front hub if it knocks your TC out as well. I had a hub go out on my silhouette van (similar if not the same front end) and it was the ABS wire getting snagged on the ball joint stud somehow and yanking it out. $35 and a chinese hub later and the light was off.

Surprised the dealer didn't go this route. You'd think they'd at least look into it. Prepare for it to be something expensive. (like the AC "Just needing a charge").
 
Originally Posted By: Trav
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
Engine and trans are likely within statistical limits for potential for failure.

The transmission yes but a good HD rebuild from triple edge takes care of that.
The engine isn't even close. I know a 16 PSI turbo doesn't bother the stock bottom end in a 3800 GT making a lot more HP than the stock GTP. The 3800 is almost bulletproof.


Just so the tune is spot on, those engines are remarkable IMO considering the humble roots...
 
Originally Posted By: eljefino
Originally Posted By: sciphi
I'd go for the '06. Chances are the ABS/TC issue is a wheel speed sensor that's integrated into the hub. That's a fairly easy fix if so. Make sure to get a name brand hub, or be prepared to do the job over and over again as the cheap ones fail repeatedly.


+2 on this and probably a front hub if it knocks your TC out as well. I had a hub go out on my silhouette van (similar if not the same front end) and it was the ABS wire getting snagged on the ball joint stud somehow and yanking it out. $35 and a chinese hub later and the light was off.

Surprised the dealer didn't go this route. You'd think they'd at least look into it. Prepare for it to be something expensive. (like the AC "Just needing a charge").

How can I diagnose the hub(s)? It looks like a replacement hub is about $90. Is it best to just replace them as a pair?
 
Originally Posted By: ls1mike
Offer 4300. Seems to me if they are asking 5200, it should not leak and the TCS/ABS light should be off.

That seems a bit low for a car whose KBB private party value is $4,400 in "Fair" conditions, which means it needs interior, exterior, and mechanical rehab. The body and interior are pristine with the exception of a minor ding on the hood, one cracked taillight, and some paint fade/wear on the front bumper (from road salt?- the car spent its first 28k miles in IL and the next 100k in IA). Most likely less than $1,000 in parts and labor make this a $6,500-$7,000 car.

I plan on offering $4,700 unless the mechanic finds something really off.
 
Originally Posted By: NMBurb02
Just got back from 6.5 hours of driving around the Inland Empire looking at Grand Prix(s). Saw five and test drove four of them: two NA and two supercharged. All I have to say about the supercharged engine is

HOLY COW! (Thought that was the best I could do without being censored.)

I didn't realize what an extra 60 hp could do, but I guess when you put it in the perspective of 30% more horsepower than NA, it makes sense. After driving one with a SC, there is no way I can settle with the NA version, premium gas and slightly lower fuel economy be [censored]! My 2008 Impala felt like a peddle car afterwards.

I think I have found "the one": 2006 Pontiac Grand Prix GT Supercharged

Love the color, it's only a 2006, it has a leather interior (black, which is problematic as I easily overheat, particularly when sitting on leather), 6-disc CD changer, and moonroof. The only problems are that the ABS and TC warning lights are on, there appears to be a slight oil leak from the valve covers (easy fix and will give me a chance to check for sludge/buildup), and the suspension felt a bit "clunky" when making a right hand turn out of a parking lot. We tried to take it to a mechanic today to do a basic inspection and have it checked out for the warning lights, but they said they had not idea what the lights were for and I skipped on having them check the whole thing over as I don't think I would trust that shop as far as I could throw it.

The owner is taking it to another mechanic tomorrow and will give me a call afterwards. I'm not too concerned about the ABS/TC as neither are really necessary here (although things may get a bit squirrelly pulling away from lights or getting on the freeway as the tires broke loose a bit when mashing the peddle on the one with functioning TC) and is a negotiating point in my favor. Thinking if I can get him down to $4,750 or even $5,000 I am getting a good deal as the KBB for private party is $6,999 Excellent, $6,624 Very Good, $6,399 Good, and $5,424 Fair.

My other option is 2004 Pontiac Grand Prix GTP. Color not as good (but still doable; not red, white, or black), cloth interior (no complaints there), single disc CD, and moonroof, but obvious leaks from the valve covers, needs two new front tires, don't like the wheels as much, and will need front brake pads soon. If the 2006 above does not work out, I will have this one checked by a mechanic and try to negotiate down to $5,500: they have had it on the lot since mid-November, the KBB private party values are $6,116/$5,791/$5,591/$4,741, and I would have to put $600+ into the car to make it worth $6,000.

And to address some concerns mentioned by others:

Originally Posted By: jsnyder49090
the lower intakes leak often as does valve covers the coolant elbows also.The blowers are solid the couplers sometimes make noise but is not that hard to repair a 20.00 part.The transmissions are problematic with higher miles they tend to shift hard when hot but they make a kit to fix and can be installed pretty easily.Look for these issues and service the trans should be good for atleast another 100,000

From what I've read, the LIM are not a problem after 2003, blowers sounded fine, and both shifted like champs (better than the NA models I tested).

Originally Posted By: JHZR2
When gas goes back over $5 will the 1-2 MPG make a difference?

If you buy the souped up version, can you afford an additional $1k part replacement?

Those are the questions Id be asking.

Not worried on either account as I can always bypass SC like Shannow said.

Originally Posted By: KD0AXS
Who drives "reasonably" in a supercharged car?
laugh.gif


I didn't think this would be a problem with me, but after test driving two, I am having second thoughts!
grin.gif


Originally Posted By: Trav
What really helps this car is Bilstein struts and GM performance chassis upgrades.
Tubular rear trailing arms, strut connectors, performance sway bars front and rear really help in handling.
I put later model impala front rotors 12" up front with Camero front twin piston calipers,
SS lines, its a huge improvement.

I'm happy with the handling but may have to do some brake upgrades as the braking performance is worse than the Burb!

Originally Posted By: supton
I'm not sure I'd buy anything used unless if I had a couple grand sitting around "just in case". Even if it checks out great, it's still used, and, stuff can and does just break. Out of the blue. That couple grand is your "warrenty" that pays for it.

Will still have $16k+ in the bank after purchase price, tax, and registration. (And no, I will not consider purchasing new to take advantage of the warranty as I do not want to be saddled with the depreciation drop, especially because I may be offered a company car again after a year.)

Originally Posted By: Jarlaxle
(In reference to no ABS/TC) AT least around here, that will make it fail inspection.
frown.gif


Surprisingly, no safety inspection in the People's Republic of California.


Well, besides the fact that Id argue that ECU tuning is likely different and youre doing yourself a disservice pulling the belt as an economizer on the blower, Id say go for it.

I kind of always wanted one of those grand prix gtp cars myself. I think its a good opportunity.

GM AC usually is pretty good, so Id not worry much about the black leather. Heck, get yourself a remote starter if it becomes that much of an issue.

Have fun!
 
Originally Posted By: JHZR2
Originally Posted By: NMBurb02
Just got back from 6.5 hours of driving around the Inland Empire looking at Grand Prix(s). Saw five and test drove four of them: two NA and two supercharged. All I have to say about the supercharged engine is

HOLY COW! (Thought that was the best I could do without being censored.)

I didn't realize what an extra 60 hp could do, but I guess when you put it in the perspective of 30% more horsepower than NA, it makes sense. After driving one with a SC, there is no way I can settle with the NA version, premium gas and slightly lower fuel economy be [censored]! My 2008 Impala felt like a peddle car afterwards.

I think I have found "the one": 2006 Pontiac Grand Prix GT Supercharged

Love the color, it's only a 2006, it has a leather interior (black, which is problematic as I easily overheat, particularly when sitting on leather), 6-disc CD changer, and moonroof. The only problems are that the ABS and TC warning lights are on, there appears to be a slight oil leak from the valve covers (easy fix and will give me a chance to check for sludge/buildup), and the suspension felt a bit "clunky" when making a right hand turn out of a parking lot. We tried to take it to a mechanic today to do a basic inspection and have it checked out for the warning lights, but they said they had not idea what the lights were for and I skipped on having them check the whole thing over as I don't think I would trust that shop as far as I could throw it.

The owner is taking it to another mechanic tomorrow and will give me a call afterwards. I'm not too concerned about the ABS/TC as neither are really necessary here (although things may get a bit squirrelly pulling away from lights or getting on the freeway as the tires broke loose a bit when mashing the peddle on the one with functioning TC) and is a negotiating point in my favor. Thinking if I can get him down to $4,750 or even $5,000 I am getting a good deal as the KBB for private party is $6,999 Excellent, $6,624 Very Good, $6,399 Good, and $5,424 Fair.

My other option is 2004 Pontiac Grand Prix GTP. Color not as good (but still doable; not red, white, or black), cloth interior (no complaints there), single disc CD, and moonroof, but obvious leaks from the valve covers, needs two new front tires, don't like the wheels as much, and will need front brake pads soon. If the 2006 above does not work out, I will have this one checked by a mechanic and try to negotiate down to $5,500: they have had it on the lot since mid-November, the KBB private party values are $6,116/$5,791/$5,591/$4,741, and I would have to put $600+ into the car to make it worth $6,000.

And to address some concerns mentioned by others:

Originally Posted By: jsnyder49090
the lower intakes leak often as does valve covers the coolant elbows also.The blowers are solid the couplers sometimes make noise but is not that hard to repair a 20.00 part.The transmissions are problematic with higher miles they tend to shift hard when hot but they make a kit to fix and can be installed pretty easily.Look for these issues and service the trans should be good for atleast another 100,000

From what I've read, the LIM are not a problem after 2003, blowers sounded fine, and both shifted like champs (better than the NA models I tested).

Originally Posted By: JHZR2
When gas goes back over $5 will the 1-2 MPG make a difference?

If you buy the souped up version, can you afford an additional $1k part replacement?

Those are the questions Id be asking.

Not worried on either account as I can always bypass SC like Shannow said.

Originally Posted By: KD0AXS
Who drives "reasonably" in a supercharged car?
laugh.gif


I didn't think this would be a problem with me, but after test driving two, I am having second thoughts!
grin.gif


Originally Posted By: Trav
What really helps this car is Bilstein struts and GM performance chassis upgrades.
Tubular rear trailing arms, strut connectors, performance sway bars front and rear really help in handling.
I put later model impala front rotors 12" up front with Camero front twin piston calipers,
SS lines, its a huge improvement.

I'm happy with the handling but may have to do some brake upgrades as the braking performance is worse than the Burb!

Originally Posted By: supton
I'm not sure I'd buy anything used unless if I had a couple grand sitting around "just in case". Even if it checks out great, it's still used, and, stuff can and does just break. Out of the blue. That couple grand is your "warrenty" that pays for it.

Will still have $16k+ in the bank after purchase price, tax, and registration. (And no, I will not consider purchasing new to take advantage of the warranty as I do not want to be saddled with the depreciation drop, especially because I may be offered a company car again after a year.)

Originally Posted By: Jarlaxle
(In reference to no ABS/TC) AT least around here, that will make it fail inspection.
frown.gif


Surprisingly, no safety inspection in the People's Republic of California.


Well, besides the fact that Id argue that ECU tuning is likely different and youre doing yourself a disservice pulling the belt as an economizer on the blower, Id say go for it.

I kind of always wanted one of those grand prix gtp cars myself. I think its a good opportunity.

GM AC usually is pretty good, so Id not worry much about the black leather. Heck, get yourself a remote starter if it becomes that much of an issue.

Have fun!

You could argue, but it you can't or don't go into boost it does not matter. The ECU ,like any looks at fuel and air. No boost, the ECU accounts for that.

The car has a bypass and will not be in boost 90 percent of the time.

If you were to Supercharge a N/A 3800 that is where the problem is. You can buy the top end upgrade for the N/A car (intake and up), that package comes with a supercharged car ECU. The blocks and crank are the same but everything else is different.
 
Don't supercharge a NA 3800. The compression ratio is wrong, the pistons and crank aren't as strong, and the PCM will need some careful tuning. There are enough supercharged 3800's out there to get one and go without the hassle of force-feeding a NA engine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom