Originally Posted By: andrewg
Originally Posted By: EType
Originally Posted By: andrewg
Why is it that whenever there is mention of shoplifting or thievery of any kind.....so many of you do everything you can to make excuses by blaming business owners and the wealthy?? It sickens me. It matters not if another person has more than you as a way of excusing or shifting focus away from common theft. Plenty of wealthy folks got that way from hard work and exhibiting integrity on their way up the economic ladder. This garbage about the 'rich' (it's become a bad word) being any more unethical than the average American is pure bunk. I'm working class myself and harbor ZERO negativity toward the wealthy. I applaud them. They provide income for others, they actually PRODUCE things and contribute to our society. No, they are not all honest or ethical....but in proportion to the average citizen I would say that they are at least equal in ethical standards if not above. I just get so tired of this constant mantra that being highly successful means you are 'bad' some way or got where you are from ripping off people. It's hogwash.
Back on the direct point....stealing has no valid excuse. Shoplifters and thieves should suffer to the highest degree possible under the law.
Interesting perspective.
Since I was the person who posted up the article about the wealthy being less ethical, perhaps I should reveal that on paper, I would indeed be one of the wealthy.
The reason for posting up something scientific is to establish a truth that is less biased than personal perspective.
My own thoughts are that many rich people do work hard - perhaps it is better to say are more disciplined, and that is certainly an admirable trait to emulate when you're trying to make it.
But part of making it requires an understanding of the system and those that really make it use the system the best and often unethically.
I am afraid to say that some poorer people, not exposed as much to how things work, simplify things and equate all success to hard work alone. Many of those people work as hard but don't make it because they're not working hard at the right things or are unwilling to compromise their ethics.
I didn't mean to attack your post in particular, but I certainly take issue with the overwhelming slant in our current culture that demonizes the wealthy as somehow evil or unethical. That was my main point about your post. It's really not the poor vs. the wealthy when it comes to right and wrong. Today, many things that used to be black and white....are suddenly subjective and permeated with excuses or blame upon somebody that has achieved more. I have known MANY lower income people that are entirely without regard when it comes to ethics....far more in proportion than the upper class folks I have known. The excuse is always something like..."Oh, they are rich....they can afford it...I deserve it anyway.....the company will never notice....they won't even notice what I take"....etc. Simply put....I honestly find that upper class folks have retained more of the traditional values that I was raised with. Manners, cleanliness, decency, ethics...all seem to be in better form with the upper class.
Just my opinion....I'm sure many will flame me here.
Not at all. You make many points I agree with. In an earlier post you mentioned that what is being stolen is often not necessary to sustain life. I agree. It's all about consumer status symbols.
Just as you have great insights and those insights matter more because they are part of your daily reality, I have some other insights through my daily realities as well as other things I investigate.
That means that if we judge this through our perspectives only, we will have definite bias.
Therefore, a scientific study is more likely to have less bias. Of course, studies can be flawed and set up in a biased way as well.