Recommend a basic cheap riding mower

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
1,108
Location
Mobile, AL
We recently bought a house with a lot that is just big enough for a rider. I don't need a large deck or a zero turn. The terrain is flat for the most part with only a couple of small trees that I just planted this spring. Before you recommend one keep in mind that I just want a basic mower that will last say 10 years. I don't need bells and whistles. I have been looking at the Troy Bilt Pony http://www.troybilt.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_10001_14102_89545_17662_-1 and a couple of inexpensive Craftsman mowers. So what inexpensive rider won't constantly throw belts and last for 10 years?
 
IMO, the main things to avoid are the "shift on the go" or variator drive systems. Pretty sure that's what this troybilt has. MTD jumped on the bandwagon now and calls some of them CVT's. A genuine gear drive is fine, as are the light hydrostatics for gentle terrain & easy mowing. The belt and variable diameter pulleys drives are not reliable. I owned one and could never keep it in adjustment. The MTD 2-blade 42" deck offers a good quality cut and gauge wheels can be purchased later on for them if needed. A 42" gear drive sears machine can be had for under a grand as well. Sears/Poulan/WeedEater/Ryobi are the same, all being made by Electrolux/AYP, then all the MTD variants.

Joel
 
I had a 38" White L-12 built by MTD. It lasted 11 years and 500+ hours and the basic mower was still usable. I junked it because the Power Brute
laugh.gif
Briggs motor was far past tired.

In the time I used it I replaced only one of each drive belt and a couple of deck belts, the front wheel bushings and one spindle assembly. I had to put tubes in the rear tires to make it through the thorns in my yard and I did buy a couple of batteries. But mine was the older model with 6 fixed speeds instead of the "CVT shift on the fly" models they're selling now.

Too bad they changed the belt "transmission" Mine was pretty reliable overall if we ignore the engine...
 
Craftsman isn't the cheapest on the market, but IMO they're one of the best values out there. My parents bought a plain-jane Craftsman push mower in 1978, mowed our residential lawn with it until 1993, gave it to their church for use on the property and to my knowledge it's still running. This is with minimalist maintenance (my dad is a tightwad). Trouble is, I don't recall what engine it had on it. Automatic choke is the only thing I remember. :-) Anyway, my point: Cheapest may not always be the best road to take when you consider repairs. My sister bought one of those el-cheapo orange riding mowers at Lowes, and never did get her lawn completely mowed with it before returning it for a refund - after 2 return trips in hope of a fix. She plunked down the cash for a John Deere 5 years ago, does her yearly maintenance and has had zero issues.
 
Quote:


My sister bought one of those el-cheapo orange riding mowers at Lowes, and never did get her lawn completely mowed with it before returning it for a refund - after 2 return trips in hope of a fix. She plunked down the cash for a John Deere 5 years ago, does her yearly maintenance and has had zero issues.




el-cheapo orange mower? Are we talking about a Husqvarna? Surely not... I thought they are good mowers.

I'm looking at a plain jane Craftsman...

http://www.sears.com/sr/javasr/product.d...UseBVCookie=Yes
 
I think that was it. Maybe she just got a bad one, but her experience was enough for me to stay away from them. She attempted to 'go cheap' and it bit her in the buttocks. She's single, stands about 5'2" tall, weighs 110 soaking wet and doesn't much enjoy loading a riding mower into her Tacoma every time it breaks, so she bought something that rarely needs a trip to the dealer. Since I started visiting her every Christmas, I just do her end-of-season maintenance while I'm there and she mows all summer trouble-free. Sista loves her JD.
 
BTW, when looking closer at the base model Troy Bilt it appears that it doesn't have the CVT junk. It just states 7 speed shift on the go.
 
Now that you can buy a new junky John Deere at Lowe's or Home Depot for $1500, the resale value on used real John Deere machines has taken a nosedive. You can buy a couple year old barely used LT or LX with a Kohler or Kawasaki, heavy frame, and 14" turning radius for $1000. That's what I would be looking at if I needed a rider. These were $2500++ machines new and are a real bargain now.
 
Quote:


Now that you can buy a new junky John Deere at Lowe's or Home Depot for $1500, the resale value on used real John Deere machines has taken a nosedive. You can buy a couple year old barely used LT or LX with a Kohler or Kawasaki, heavy frame, and 14" turning radius for $1000. That's what I would be looking at if I needed a rider. These were $2500++ machines new and are a real bargain now.




The dealers around here sure haven't gotten the word. They seem to think if it's Green it's still worth 75% of original price at 20 years...
 
Quote:


Who sells Poulan?




Home Depot & box stores sold them. Not sure if they are still avail or not.

In regards to the JD 100 series, I agree they are good lawn tractor for the money. Decent steering, decks and TuffTorq hydros, but they are $1500 vs. $1000 or less for gear trans MTD LT.

Joel
 
Quote:


The dealers around here sure haven't gotten the word. They seem to think if it's Green it's still worth 75% of original price at 20 years...




Same here JS. Dealer prices for used are insane and if you are lucky enough to find a private sale of something decent, you better move fast!

Joel
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom