Looked at a Civic Hybrid w/Navigation

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 30, 2004
Messages
33,966
Location
CA
Today, I went out and looked at a 2007 Civic Hybrid w/Navigation. Sticker price was only $24,945, before the $2100 Federal Tax Credit.

I didn't drive one, but I sat in it and looked around under the hood and such. I must say, that the Navigation system is excellent, and the Digital Audio Card Reader is a nice touch. The interior is of a good quality, better than the Camry Hybrid that I sat in at the school shop. The rear seat is surprisingly roomy for a small car, and the front seat is much more comfortable than the Saturn.

As for maintenance, under-the-hood room is TIGHT; I repeat, TIGHT. I thought the Saturn was BAD, but this was worse. Even the transmission dipstick is located in a funny place.

Required engine oil is 0w-20 synthetic, and service intervals are determined by the Maintenance Minder system. Users seem to be going 6-8k between service. Transmission takes Honda's new CVT Fluid, no longer ATF-Z1. The new CVT fluid costs $10/qt, which is a little less than Toyota's WS fluid. Difference? Based on field reports, Honda's new Maintenance Minder System, combined with its first ATF life monitor, has been recommending a service every 20-30k miles on these units. Luckily, it only takes 3 quarts to service (Unit holds 5-ish), so it isn't too bad, but consider that the Prius requires no ATF service at all, and there've been no reports about transmission failure.

All in all, the Civic Hybrid appears to be a promising candidate. It's not quite as large as my neighbor's 05 Prius, lacks the cargo flexibility (No 60/40 rear seatback folddown), and delivers lesser fuel economy compared to the Prius, but it certainly beats the Prius in price, especially with the current tax credit, which I hope will remain in effect until next spring in the full amount.

At the current price, I can buy the model w/Navigation, and provided that I obtain 33MPG throughout the life of the vehicle (150k miles), versus 25 for the gas-only model, I can recoup the added cost over the EX model, and enjoy a Navigation system. And I even confirmed, warranty on the Hybrid components is 15-yr/150k miles in CA, and 10-yr/150k miles on the Battery pack.

Happy Holidays to everyone!
 
Oh, and I went ahead and did the calculations again to make sure I can recoup the added cost, I don't want to lose:

Car A:

2007 Honda Civic EX Automatic
$18,452 purchase cost (Listed Invoice)
25 mpg lifetime average

Car B:
2007 Honda Civic Hybrid w/Navigation
$22,845 purchase cost (MSRP- $2100 Federal Tax Credit)
33 mpg lifetime average
10-yr/150k mi warranty on Battery Pack (CA)
15-yr/150k mi warranty on Emission Components (CA)

Cost Difference: $4393

Fuel Cost over 150k miles, @ $3.00/gal:

Car A: $13,636
Car B: $18,000

Cost savings: $4,364

I guess the real question is whether or not my parents and I want to drive a lawnmower for the next 150k miles.
 
Don't count on the extra mpg being there. Resale should help the numbers on the Hybrid. Still, I am not a fan. I'm looking at sedans for my mom to replace her trusty 96 Passat. I keep coming back to the Jetta when cost is a factor. <$20k gets a nice one.
 
Quote:


Don't count on the extra mpg being there. Resale should help the numbers on the Hybrid.



The Hybrid will obtain about 1/3 better economy than the conventional Civic, which is reasonable IMO. I'm not expecting exceptionally good #s. If it can get lower 30s in town, I would already break even.
 
I think you have the car A/B gas cost amounts flip flopped?

Quote:


I'm not expecting exceptionally good #s. If it can get lower 30s in town, I would already break even.




you're aiming pretty low, unless you drive like an auto magazine editor
ooo.gif
I get low-mid 30s in town in my non-hybrid 05 Civic automatic (lifetime mpg sitting at 42.8MPG through >21k miles)
 
Last edited:
Woops!
pat2.gif


On average, how many miles in length are your trips? I figure that with 1-3 mi trips, and based upon what I read on GreenHybrid, low-mid 30s would be a conservative estimate, and that I shouldn't expect to break 40.
 
my commute is 72 mile roundtrip - primarily highway and I drive 50-55mph (my scangauge has made all the difference with MPG too).

I guess I remembered incorrectly that folks with the HCHII were getting a bit higher MPG, maybe I wasn't paying attention to the whether or not they had short trips.
 
Well, one of the folks who works at the school I attend owns a 2006 Civic Hybrid, and her 30+ mi commute @ 70 mph effortlessly yields 49-50 mpg. And I doubt she implements any techniques to maximize efficiency, either.
 
Second the Corolla.. Sticks tend to average about 41 mpg (US) and autos about 38 mpg (US) highway.

However if you want a Hybrid there is certainly nothing wrong with the Civic... Also now that Prius production has caught up you can get them below MSRP.

PS I dont even now why I get into these discussions as my pickup gets 11.0 mpg city and 20.0 mpg highway. My "work" vehicle has averaged 6.7 mpg for the last 100,000 mi.
 
Except the Corolla is ancient in every other way possible. And resale sucks too.

The Auto Corolla gets upper 30s on the road, but in-town, it only gets mid-20s.
 
I don't know where you're getting these mpg figures. Just get the most fuel efficient gas engine car you can find, i wouldn't go the hybrid route. I'd go with the civic ex.
 
My Corolla fuel consumption is based over 4 months and 6k miles of varied driving. I check every tankful with the mileage driven and expect to get even better consumption as the car gets a little older. The Corolla is a superb basic mode of transport, well built, strong, easy to drive and cheap maintain and run, which is what every car should aspire to. They are after all means of transport and not Gods to be worshipped.
Roger
 
1-3 miles trips sort of stuff making gas mileage or hybrids your top choice. Th whole process looks driven by what you want and then making the numbers fit. That's ok as most people should buy what they want. But what I see is you want a compact and decided on a Civic which carries a $2-$3k premium over other comparable compacts and now you've got the another $2 -$3K into a hybrid choice when a new or used compact for $10 -14K would more than meet your requirements to go to school for a few years.
 
I drove a Civic Hybrid and it's a bit rough around the edges. The engine shakes on start up and shut down and transitions are rough too, during normal driving. I wonder if the CNG Civic is a better deal?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom