Originally Posted By: benjamming
What's the rule of thumb for when to file a claim vs. pay out of pocket re: rate hikes, driver being moved to the new vehicle, etc.?
There is no rule of thumb, unfortunately. You have to look at your deductible, the total estimate, any possibility of hidden damage which would increase the final repair bill, and how much you think your insurance will go up based on the additional accident. The insurance company couldn't tell you how much your rate would go up at the end of your policy term even if they wanted to. They may or may not find out about the accident (based on your driving record) even if you don't make a claim.
Anyone who attempts to give you an absolute answer to your question is probably ill-informed.
By the way, $500 is by far the most common collision deductible - you've done nothing wrong there.