Some of the tires I have had experiences with :
BFGoodrich Traction T/A : Decent treadlife, good traction in snow/rain, LOUD and rode stiff.
Goodyear Eagle RS-A : Decent Treadwear, good ride quality, got loud towards the end of their life, decent all season traction. ( They didnt really stand out in any manner for me if that makes any sense )
Bridgestone Grid G019 : Excellent All season traction, I was able to drive around in light snow with tread down to 5/32nds. STIFF ride, LOUD and will cup no matter how often you align your vehicle and rotate your tires.
Falken Zeix 512 : [censored]
Goodyear Triple Tread ( old version ) : Phenomenal traction in dry/wet/snow for an all season tire. Distinct hum ( They were on a civic which is a loud car in itself ), stiffish ride and loss in mpg ( Hwy mpg went down by 3 mpgs ).
Goodyear Assurance Comfortred Touring : Current tires on my daily driver. Good dry/wet traction, will squeel a bit in dry and not as grippy in wet as I would like them to be. Snow/Ice traction however is excellent. I have driven in blizzards and ice storms without issues. Plenty of warning before they break lose. Ride comfort and quietness is better than any of the above listed tires. Treadwear seems spot on for the 70k treadlife warranty and I dont drive this car easy. Its been lowered and has upgrade sway bars as well.
Goodyear Eagle F1 All Season : AWESOME wet/dry traction. STIFF ride for the first 1000 miles while they break in, then it softens up quite a bit. Has a distinct hum to them, especially when you are coasting. Good snow traction.
Goodyear Assurance Triple Tread All Season : Excellent wet traction, havent driven in snow yet. Good dry traction ( more than Comfortreds, less than Eagle F1 ). Will grip but will squeel while doing so. Again better ride than Eagle F1 but harsher/louder than Comfortreds.
Havent found my perfect tire yet, the search continues .........