child support advise pls

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI

The legal system in this country when it comes to divorce and custody is stacked against the man in a HUGE way.

You are only looking at one side of it. My daughter went through a divorce 6 years ago. She gets $950 dollars of support to raise 3 kids. The home equity was to be split in half. The Husband kept dragging his feet. The court didn't hold him in contempt as they should have. and ultimately declared bankruptcy. 42 years ago. My daughter paid for most of the house when they were married.

Family court is a joke. The legal system in this country is a joke. Also go into a woman abuse center and talk to them there about how the man always gets screwed.

He took my daughter back into court 9 times. (cost her about 1500 every time)


1st of all we are not talking about physical abuse here. That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

I am looking at it from the info provided and from a view point where I have never seen any outcome but the man screwed over and in a HUGE way. Yes, there are times when the man is the issue and deserves every thing he gets( cheats, abusive, etc... ). I am not anti woman or anything just someone who is honest about how it is in this country these days. I wouldn't dare get married if I had any real money behind me even with a pre-nup. Just too big a risk.

In a divorce and/or custody battle most times, in these days, the man gets royally reamed out even when he has done nothing wrong. You need the best lawyer there is just to not lose every cent you have or will ever have. Forget coming out of it with a fair and equitable settlement. Plan on coming out on the short stick even if you have done nothingw rong and she is an abuser, cheats on you, and the divorce was all her idea.

No person who can look at divorce/custody in this country, these days, with an honest and unbiased view point, could say anything but the odds are all stacked against the man. Doesn't matter if he is a batterer or a saint he will get treated the same.

Try this. In my friends divorce I talk of earlier the ex asked the MM to award her my friend's Dad's antique train set( big set worth a lot - approx 15 grand )when he passed on. It is in his will that it go to my friend. Now, the MM did not award it to her BUT he did take the value of it and count it towards what my friend got in the settlement. Please don't talk to me about who paid most towards what when something left to you in a will, that is not yours at the time of the divorce, counts towards your settlement figure. This was something that did not even belong to my friend yet the value was included in the divorce. Fair? Hardly.

His ex repeatedely signed her spousal rights to my friends property away as well( rental house, their home, etc... )yet in the divorce she got it ALL. He had to sell all of his stocks, cash in his 401K, leave the hosue he alone paid for( she never contributed to it ), and on and on and split it with her. These are things he ahd prior to the marriage. He is flat broke now with NOTHING left for his hard work. If not for his dad helping him find a place to live he would be homeless.

Try this one on.. The MM said because he left the house prior to the divorce, and the ex lived there during the time the divorce was ongoing, that she should get it. Of course he is the one that ordered my friend out of the house. He did not leave the house the MM kicked him out! The MM then says because he left it should be hers. Fair? Hardly.

THAT is the kind of bull puckey I am talking about that goes on men face these days in divorce/custody hearings. I am afraid my friend will wind up in jail. He is out of work an unable to pay $1500 a month let alone $14000 in back CS that is totally bogus. My friend spends every cent he has on his kids. He is no dead beat. He goes without himself so they have everything they need. The ex does NOTHING for the kids and does not need the money and will only use it for her needs not the kids. His ex makes over $100K a year as said and my friend is now barely making $20K in part time construction management work when he can pick up a project now and then( construction field is DEAD up here ).

I am sorry your daughter had a hard time but PLEASE don't think that is the norm.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: kb01
Maybe I'm just missing something really obvious but...

I'm not sure what a lawyer is going to be able to do when you have no proof that payments were ever made. Even though it works 99% of the time, paying cash with no receipt for a contractual obligation is a horrible idea.


He'd paid cash BEFORE he was actually ordered to pay child support. Once there was a court order, he paid by check. His ex is trying to claim the support she was paid by cash is in arrears, which unless the court order was retroactive (something the court can't do in my jurisdiction, but may be different in his), the OP is only on the hook for support after the entry of the court order. If he's not behind on that, he should not have a problem. But he's going to need a lawyer to "persuade" the child support enforcement robots of this fact.
 
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI

1st of all we are not talking about physical abuse here. That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

Ummmm...it doesn't need to be "Physical Abuse"..in fact a lot of it isn't

Also I'm guessing G-Man will disagree with much of what you have said...I could be wrong.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI

1st of all we are not talking about physical abuse here. That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

Ummmm...it doesn't need to be "Physical Abuse"..in fact a lot of it isn't

Also I'm guessing G-Man will disagree with much of what you have said...I could be wrong.


Abuse is abuse is abuse be it mental or physical. I was not diminishing that in the least. However, that is soemthing totally irrelevant to this topic. This is about child support payments not abused women.

What have I posted that he will disagree with? I posted what has actually happened to my friend recently so hard for him to disagree with that. As far as saying the system is stacked against the man I think his posts tend to at least side somewhat with me not against me but whatever makes you happy man.

Have a good one.
 
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.
 
upgdate, I come to the lady that handle my case, i told she that i want dispute and hire a lawyer, she say ok. AND I did some mistake and give u guy the wrong info about the date on court order me pay child support . COURT ORDER ME TO PAY CHILD SUPPORT START FROM JUNE 2009

from June 2009 to march 2010, I HAVE NO PROOF IN THESE MONTH, we was cool and still hang out together, so I give she cash, I think that was its and y I dont write check to her. because we cool and hang out regularly

June 2009 to August 2009 SHE SAY I ALREADY PAY
Sep 2009 til December 2009 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, these month we still hang out and cool, so I give her cash, but i have no proof

Jan 2010 to Feb 2010 SHE SAY I PAY, BUT I DONT HAVE ANY PROOF ON IT ETHER

March 2010 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, I pay her cash this time too

April 2010 THIS IS WHEN WE HAVE BIG FIGHT AND I START WRITING HER CHECK !

May 2010 and June 2010 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, 2 of these month im confused alot other thing like, pay her traffic ticket, and other one buy brake pad for her car, and she say take off those child support moneys and pay the traffic ticket and brake pad, rotor, or she saw me sold my mustang and asking if i can pay her 1 month ahead, since she need moneys, and i did BUT IM DONT HAVE PROOF ON THIS

July-august 2010 SHE SAY I PAY, AND I GOT PROOF OF IT

Sep-December 2010 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, BUT I HAVE PROOF I DID PAY

Jan 2011 I send her 120 CHECK AND OWN SHE 100 DOLLAR

Feb-March 2011 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, BUT I HAVE PROOF I DID PAY

I did cal up and count those month I have no proof, total i own is around 1300 dollar. I did pay those month I have no proof cause I pay cash, but im screw cause i pay in cash and have no proof.

BTW SHE DID NOT TRY TO GET MONEYS BEFORE COURT ORDER ME FOR CHILD SUPPORT, JUST WHEN COURT ORDER ME TIL NOW. BECAUSE TODAY I FIND OUT EXACTLY DATE OF COURT ORDER ME.

BTW I hope u guy get whole story now. for those month I did pay and have no proof that. now wat ?


I CALL MY EX TODAY , and i talk to her about the child support she fill out, alot a mistake and she know I pay her. she say few month ago she talk to me, say i have to go get my daughter back from another country, and I disagree, cause many reason,
she was pregnant that time, and go thru alot [censored],
she still have no job to support.
many thing will happent if my daughter back here, alot more drama between me and my ex, and I dont want my daughter to be in middle of it.
my daughter is happy with her grandma atm, she still talk to her mom and I regularly over the phone.

AFTER TALK TO SHE, SHE SAY THE REASON SHE DOING CHILD SUPPORT PAYPER THING, CAUSE I WAS DISAGREE ABOUT PAYING AIR PLANE TICKET FOR ME TO GET MY DAUGHTER BACK HERE. YES SHE SAY I PAY ALL. i know she have no moneys, cause she dont work.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It would seem to me that if the child is in a different country (removed illegally?) under the care of someone else, that there would be grounds to remove the CS payments?

Quote:
In a divorce and/or custody battle most times, in these days, the man gets royally reamed out even when he has done nothing wrong.


Has been my personal experience. And my ex had a domestic conviction!
 
Quote:
Sep-December 2010 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, BUT I HAVE PROOF I DID PAY

Jan 2011 I send her 120 CHECK AND OWN SHE 100 DOLLAR

Feb-March 2011 SHE SAY IM NOT PAY, BUT I HAVE PROOF I DID PAY

This may help your case as it shows she is not being honest or at least is not keeping good records.

In court, if you can't prove it, it usually didn't happen (to the judge).

I'm not a lawyer but I've been through all this. I pay my ex ahead of time to show good faith in case a problem arises.
 
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.


This is relevant because when the party wanting the divorce starts talking to an attorney (but is still married) the attorney will goad him/her into becoming a "victim" of abuse. This party will then taunt the spouse and try to create a police record of the slightest bump or scratch.

One needs to spot this trap as it goes down.
 
Originally Posted By: Tempest
It would seem to me that if the child is in a different country (removed illegally?) under the care of someone else, that there would be grounds to remove the CS payments?

Quote:
In a divorce and/or custody battle most times, in these days, the man gets royally reamed out even when he has done nothing wrong.


Has been my personal experience. And my ex had a domestic conviction!


I did sign the paper for my child to travel back with her grandma, I think it best for she. because that time, thing is all mess up, my ex in the middle of possible deporting back to her country, cause she got caught with no DL, and have no proof of ID that she can stay here in USA. and she and I was in the middle of big fight, alot of thing happent at the same time, we all decise to let my babe going back with her grandma. I love my child, but I still think she have to stay other their for now, til thing getting better.
 
Originally Posted By: eljefino
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.


This is relevant because when the party wanting the divorce starts talking to an attorney (but is still married) the attorney will goad him/her into becoming a "victim" of abuse. This party will then taunt the spouse and try to create a police record of the slightest bump or scratch.

One needs to spot this trap as it goes down.


yub I did have a domestic violent, and they use that reason to help the divorse case, i was bite the bullet and take all the charge for myself, because she hit my face 2 time, and i slighly hit her face back ( not punch ), in police record my ex say i only hit she, she dint say nothing about she hit me, it was wrong report she make up, but i just take the charge for myself anyway, cause i was still love she and dont want nothing happent to she.
 
Originally Posted By: Papa Bear
Oh, man !! .....

Looking forward to G-Man or Win's next post .


I hope somthing good from them, i have not find lawyer yet.
 
How soon until she has baby # 2 and you become a dad again ?

Would you sell your car to hire a good lawyer and clear up all this mess ?

You said you live with your parents, what do they say about this game she is playing ?
 
Originally Posted By: LT4 Vette
How soon until she has baby # 2 and you become a dad again ?

Would you sell your car to hire a good lawyer and clear up all this mess ?

You said you live with your parents, what do they say about this game she is playing ?




she already have her baby, i think at 2 month or so, no its not my baby

thing getting a little better since I see thing clearly now, I did some month i got proof and some month i dint get any proof, from 3k now after those month i got proof, i only own about 1300 of no proof. event i go court and loose i wont have to sell my car to pay that. mabe court let me pay extra each month on child support til 1300 gone. that still better then 3k im worried about. but I dont know, imma try to find a lawyer, talk to them about this, let see wat they say, then i start hire them.

I dont talk about it to my parent.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Originally Posted By: Papa Bear
Oh, man !! .....

Looking forward to G-Man or Win's next post .


I've said everything that needs to be said: He needs a lawyer.
 
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.


Women file 2/3rds to 3/4s of all divorce actions.

Abuse or Unfaithfulness by the husband being divorced is present in 6% of cases. That means that 60% percent of divorces involve neither abuse, nor betrayal on the part of the man being divorced.

Don't buy the lie that women are victims and men are perpetrators. Bad marital conduct is not a gender trait, it's a character trait.

Even if you believe that only men cheat, who are they having affairs with, other men? Of course not. Now those women may not know he's married (how stupid can they be?) but they have to know he's not their husband since we can assume they know their own marital status.

Therefore, men and women are equally represented in affairs. Just because she may or may not be married doesn't mean she's not cheating the betrayed spouse.

This comes from my experience as a divorced man with an unfaithful ex-wife.

Don't buy the lies that men are perpetrators and women are victims. My ex-wife knew the guy she left to have her affair was married. She did it anyway. And of course asked for everything.

Since she had been a stay at home mom, she got primary, but not sole custody. I kept the home.

Guys, if your wife says she loves you, but isn't in love with you, send her packing. Don't allow her to take the kids, don't allow her to make you leave the marital home.

You can't prevent her from having an affair, but you don't have to allow her to take the kids or the house when she's doing it.

Remember, marital misconduct is not a gender issue, as both genders have equal representation as affair participants. Marital misconduct is a character issue. And people with bad character are represented equally in both genders.
 
Originally Posted By: eljefino
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.


This is relevant because when the party wanting the divorce starts talking to an attorney (but is still married) the attorney will goad him/her into becoming a "victim" of abuse. This party will then taunt the spouse and try to create a police record of the slightest bump or scratch.

One needs to spot this trap as it goes down.


It doesn't usually matter. I never as much as yelled at my unfaithful ex-wife. However, she assaulted me and I CALLED THE COPS. Not that I was hurt, but to protect myself.

They didn't care. It didn't mean a thing.

It's a one way street, and it's not in the man's favor, even if he is the recipient of the assault.
 
Originally Posted By: javacontour
Originally Posted By: eljefino
Originally Posted By: Al
Originally Posted By: NHHEMI
That is 100% a different topic than what is going on in this thread. A woman's abuse shelter is not relevant to this topic IMO.

It was brought up in response to indicating the Man is mostly screwed. Abuse shelters can shed perspective on your incorrect assertion....

My point (in case you still don't understand) is that a large number of divorces are bc of "abuse" (physical/mental.) And if the man "Usually gets screwed"..there is a disconnect between your reality and reality.


This is relevant because when the party wanting the divorce starts talking to an attorney (but is still married) the attorney will goad him/her into becoming a "victim" of abuse. This party will then taunt the spouse and try to create a police record of the slightest bump or scratch.

One needs to spot this trap as it goes down.


It doesn't usually matter. I never as much as yelled at my unfaithful ex-wife. However, she assaulted me and I CALLED THE COPS. Not that I was hurt, but to protect myself.

They didn't care. It didn't mean a thing.

It's a one way street, and it's not in the man's favor, even if he is the recipient of the assault.


Exactly!
 
update : today I call bunch of lawyer
their is 2 lawyer I call today and 2 of them charge 250 dollar 1 hours, just to sit down and talk and give me some advice on my case

another lady i call she talk to me over the phone, say charge 250 1 hours, but she did give me some free advise, she also say i can represent myself on my case. she say just tell the judge the true, and those moneys u gave to her is cash when u guy was still hang out together, but after u guy not talk no more, that when u pay check, just tell the judge that. she did say " y do u have to pay child support when your child is not in USA atm ? " she say I dont have to pay child support when my child is not in state. i told she i just want to do the right thing.

I call daughter today and speak to her grandma, the one been taking care my daughter, asking her FOR THE FIRST TIME IN 5 YEARS, " DID MY EX GIVE MY DAUGHTER MONEYS THAT I SEND HER " she say no, some time my ex buy cloth and stuff , but never give moneys to my kids, I already know that. but I want she to tell me the true.

their are 2 more lawyer I waiting for them to call, and I did call the Legal aid thing, and they asking me , that I have to show every person that live with me income on my household. my dad made good amount moneys a year, but he struggle with deb atm too, so i dont want bother him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom