Originally Posted By: ARCOgraphite
Proper viscosity is not validated by wear measure - a light grade could be showing OK wear then - BANG! Thats what a safety margin is. Floor the car to pass a truck - engine is at redline - BANG! Most catastrophic wear particulate end up in the filter not the UOA - you can have a broken engine show 20ppm Fe, Al, Cr, Si.
I agree with your statements. We are talking about the difference between a dino 5w30 vs a semi syn 5w20. We are not talking a huge spread here, and it is his wifes daily driver that goes 15 miles to work and back with some running around mixed in. These engines have done very well on generic 5w30, one run on a 5w20 thru the winter will not hurt this truck. Would i recommend running it forever, no but one run wont hurt it a bit. This being said, there have been some good points brought up about why maybe not to run it. Afterall were talking about 11 bucks to stop at walmart and pick up some 5w30 and everyone is happy. Mix the 5w20 in small doses until it gone. Problem solved and oil gets used. Happy and no waste. GTG