Originally Posted By: yonyon
Originally Posted By: eljefino
There's a spring in the socket that pushes the ball up against the top of the socket. The base of the socket pulls up into the control arm. If you pull on the stud hard enough that the ball is pulling up against the top of its socket with much more force than the spring is giving, then it gets tight.
What you're saying would make sense if the knuckle were jammed tight up against the axle beam. If that were the case, you'd already have a problem of the steering being jammed.
At this point I'm pretty much convinced this is just an old fish story. If I overtighten my lugs that somehow make the wheel bearing stiff and give me bad fuel economy?
We do at least 5 sets of these joints per week and i have seen it many times screwed up by other technicians. I've explained in the best way that i can. The only other way i can show you is first had and that is impossible.
Next time you do a set of these, really crank on the castle nut for the lower ball joint, then try to move the knuckle back and forth. Then, torque it to proper spec (setting the joints each time), and you will be able to feel a clear difference in turning force needed to move the knuckle back and forth.