10 bucks says that three quarters of the people who saw a mileage increase fall into one of these categories
people who drove in a more fuel conscience manner
people who went by only one or two measurements before and after treatment
people who just figure their mileage based on "about how many miles before the tank is low"
people who never figured into the equation tire pressure, or weight changes in the car (did you happen to finish your Auto-RX treatment the same weekend you cleaned out your trunk?)
people who never factored in weather changes.
My point is this, I don't doubt that for some cars Auto-RX improves mileage by 1-3mpg, but here's what I do know, ethenol, air temp, tire PSI, weight, a different commute, different driving style (like coasting down hills, and not accelerating before an impending stop) can all effect mileage by a few MPG, and it's hard to negate all the factors.
I keep track of my fuel mileage with a spreadsheet. But that's because I'm a computer nut who is very interested in fuel economy. ;-)
And BTW, Auto-RX didn't improve my mileage at all.