I've always been a bit curious about the MotorCraft filters for my vehicles since they have a good reputation and are a good price as well. I just never knew which filter # would fit.
When I first bought my new '04 Altima 2.5, every filter I bought/used gave me startup rattle even PureOne, Nissan filters and just about every other brand. I tried ST filters and they were the worst. NAPA Pro Select finaly made the rattling STOP!
Today, I have had great success with PuroClassic since they change the name from Premium Plus(I don't know why!).
I have been staying with what works these days and right now, it's the Puro Classic's that have given me the best, most consistant success. The Classic's are always available, often on sale/rebate, or come w/ an OCI special. Now, the car would have to be setting for several days without starting to get the startup rattle, or parked on an angle(driver side lower than the pass side).
These 1st gen 2.5/3.5 Nissan engines are rattlers on their best day even if they don't rattle opon startup. They'll rattle for a few minutes when first driving off mainly from the first startup for the day or after sitting for several hours such as in you work parking lot for 8 hrs.