The TG is still a fiber endcap design, but it's similar to many of the 'made for' OEM's like Honda and Subaru. It also has a silicone adbv, which is better than the nitrile on the HMF. I would take it over the HM, or orange can, if they would let you substitute. And no goo.
I'd prefer the P1, but the ones I listed, should be close to the same price as or less than the HMF.
As for the use of the oil extending goo being used back in the 70's, oils have come a long way in that time. I don't want a filter company picking the additives in my oil.
Pick a good oil and a good filter, run reasonable OCI or as dictated by the owners manual. That should work just fine.