Recent Topics
Manual Transmissions and DI/GDI engine issues
by Speak2Mountain
10/21/17 10:22 AM
Why would a short OCI clean better?
by MoreCowbellAz
10/21/17 10:21 AM
Where are the awesome first time lease deals?
by ZZman
10/21/17 10:14 AM
2001 Dodge 2500, 388k miles, 36k OCI on RT6
by A_Harman
10/21/17 10:04 AM
Costco Michelin X-Tour tire review
by Cujet
10/21/17 09:56 AM
How is Bitog Pronouced?
by rollinpete
10/21/17 09:56 AM
Cracked Head *pics*
by tomcruise
10/21/17 09:21 AM
Schaeffer Application Question
by Gebo
10/21/17 09:10 AM
Cayenne drain plug obstruction
by pda1122
10/21/17 08:15 AM
Castrol Woobie
by 07Piloteer
10/21/17 07:30 AM
1987 Toyota 22R 148KMi Valve cover pics
by Jason_Michaels
10/21/17 07:17 AM
Parts store websites
by dlundblad
10/21/17 07:13 AM
LSP3 VS FLUID FILM
by wantboost
10/21/17 02:44 AM
Phone App for Monitoring WiFi OBDII Port Adaptor
by ZeeOSix
10/21/17 01:36 AM
Mercedes Electric AA Class
by StevieC
10/21/17 01:17 AM
Reliability Ratings Article
by StevieC
10/21/17 12:43 AM
14 F-150 Ecoboost -12k miles -MC blend or PZ Full?
by DirtyApe
10/20/17 11:24 PM
Sticking with one oil brand for life of vehicle?
by wemay
10/20/17 09:44 PM
How much will a v belt stretch?
by motor_oil_madman
10/20/17 08:47 PM
Aerospace Protectant
by StevieC
10/20/17 08:45 PM
Newest Members
bsmith6356, RaisinCane, thkilroy, perknz, JEByrd
63172 Registered Users
Who's Online
84 registered (aquariuscsm, alphadog, 2015_PSD, Anduril, barkingspider, Best F100, 5 invisible), 2222 Guests and 15 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
63172 Members
66 Forums
272551 Topics
4525103 Posts

Max Online: 3590 @ 01/24/17 08:07 PM
Donate to BITOG
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >
Topic Options
#2460962 - 12/12/11 10:58 PM Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB)
johnsmellsalot Offline


Registered: 07/02/11
Posts: 526
Loc: Texas
I'm wondering which oil returns better used oil analyses.
_________________________
1999 Buick Century 180,000 miles (first car)
2008 Chrysler PT Cruiser 70,000 miles

Top
#2460964 - 12/12/11 10:59 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
OVERKILL Offline


Registered: 04/28/08
Posts: 34219
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: johnsmellsalot
I'm wondering which oil returns better used oil analyses.


You can't compare UOA's on different oils.

/Thread
_________________________
2016 Durango Limited
2016 Grand Cherokee SRT

Top
#2460967 - 12/12/11 11:03 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
LoneRanger Offline


Registered: 07/02/07
Posts: 3417
Loc: Midwest USA
Check out a VOA of both side by side here:

http://www.pqiamerica.com/testresultssep2011.html

PYB seems the stronger oil based on this VOA.

_________________________

'09 Subaru Forester ...................(QSED DEXOS1 5W30)
'16 Moto Guzzi Stelvio 1200 .....(ENI i-Ride PG 10W60)

Top
#2460969 - 12/12/11 11:04 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
mongo161 Offline


Registered: 07/11/10
Posts: 3608
Loc: Ponte Vedra Beach, FL
Both oils are great quality oils in conventional.
_________________________
I get by with a little help from my friends....listen with your eyes....it's the ONLY way to believe what you hear...

Top
#2460970 - 12/12/11 11:05 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: OVERKILL]
Big_Kat Offline


Registered: 10/31/09
Posts: 525
Loc: Iowa
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL
Originally Posted By: johnsmellsalot
I'm wondering which oil returns better used oil analyses.


You can't compare UOA's on different oils.

/Thread


Isn't that like saying you can't compare which medicine works better overall in a medical study. I'm sure we could compile all the UOAs on the two oils and do an ANOVA test to determine if there is a difference.
_________________________
2011 Jeep Compass 8000 mile OCI

Where would life be without mutations?

Top
#2460972 - 12/12/11 11:08 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: LoneRanger]
johnsmellsalot Offline


Registered: 07/02/11
Posts: 526
Loc: Texas
I am very familiar with that website. I like that Pennzoil has the most moly. I was wondering about Valvoline because It doesn't have hardly any moly in it.
Originally Posted By: LoneRanger
Check out a VOA of both side by side here:

http://www.pqiamerica.com/testresultssep2011.html

PYB seems the much stronger oil based on this VOA.

_________________________
1999 Buick Century 180,000 miles (first car)
2008 Chrysler PT Cruiser 70,000 miles

Top
#2460974 - 12/12/11 11:10 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: Big_Kat]
abycat Offline


Registered: 12/06/10
Posts: 2007
Loc: grande prairie AB
The mobil super looks really good on paper as well.
_________________________
2004 f350 6.0
2011 nissan versa hb

Top
#2460980 - 12/12/11 11:16 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
LoneRanger Offline


Registered: 07/02/07
Posts: 3417
Loc: Midwest USA
Well, moly isn't everything. Ti is the new moly. Maybe.
_________________________

'09 Subaru Forester ...................(QSED DEXOS1 5W30)
'16 Moto Guzzi Stelvio 1200 .....(ENI i-Ride PG 10W60)

Top
#2460981 - 12/12/11 11:17 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: Big_Kat]
OVERKILL Offline


Registered: 04/28/08
Posts: 34219
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: Big_Kat
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL
Originally Posted By: johnsmellsalot
I'm wondering which oil returns better used oil analyses.


You can't compare UOA's on different oils.

/Thread


Isn't that like saying you can't compare which medicine works better overall in a medical study. I'm sure we could compile all the UOAs on the two oils and do an ANOVA test to determine if there is a difference.


No, because unless you are going to be doing tear-downs (real data) the "data" you end up with is meaningless.

You can perform VOA's and speculate as to an oil's potential capabilities/strengths. You can compare TBN retention and determine which oil is the longest lasting and perhaps base your oil choice (I can run this oil longer!) on that. But you can't compare which oil is giving you the "best protection" without actual wear data, something that cannot be extracted from UOA's. It requires tear-downs and actual measurements.
_________________________
2016 Durango Limited
2016 Grand Cherokee SRT

Top
#2460987 - 12/12/11 11:33 PM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
Dakota1820 Offline
formerly chevyboy14


Registered: 04/28/11
Posts: 3894
Loc: missouri usa
I agree Id use Mobil over those two
_________________________
2004 Honda civic vp -m1 5w30
1998 Saturn sl2 -mobil super 5000 5w30


Top
#2460996 - 12/13/11 12:22 AM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
oilmaven Offline


Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 728
Loc: Northern Michigan
Although I've never been a big fan of Valvoline and it looks "weak", it returns surprisingly good UOA's. There does seem to be more than meets the eye when it comes to the quality of the oil based on the UOA's vs. the info. one sees on paper. My choice in a conventional oil has always been PYB but any of these will serve well. I also like the specs and UOA's I've seen for Quaker State.
_________________________
2010 Suzuki Kizashi-Pennzoil Platinum Pureplus 5W30
2013 Toyota Prius-Pennzoil Platinum 0W20

Top
#2460998 - 12/13/11 12:26 AM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: oilmaven]
ltslimjim Offline


Registered: 08/06/10
Posts: 5637
Loc: WatUpDoc
Originally Posted By: oilmaven
Although I've never been a big fan of Valvoline and it looks "weak", it returns surprisingly good UOA's. There does seem to be more than meets the eye when it comes to the quality of the oil based on the UOA's vs. the info. one sees on paper. My choice in a conventional oil has always been PYB but any of these will serve well. I also like the specs and UOA's I've seen for Quaker State.


...and it smells good, too! thumbsup

Seriously! grin2
_________________________
92 Civic Hatch (stolen frown RIP)
07 Honda Fit Sport (A/T) WELCOME thumbsup

Top
#2461073 - 12/13/11 06:37 AM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: OVERKILL]
Radman Offline


Registered: 11/24/10
Posts: 485
Loc: Detroit, Michigan
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL
You can't compare UOA's on different oils.


I am on a Nissan forum and my engine the 35VQDE is tough on shearing oil. All of us pooled our UOA's to find out which oils performed better. Most oils sheared out of grade. Castrols did the best with GTX out performing many of the synthetics.

Granted not many engines are as hard on oil as the 35VQDE. Although it is every mans perogative to compare and purchase whatever they want.
_________________________
2006 Maxima 120K M1-105, M1 0W40
2006 Sentra 90K M1-105, GTX 5W30
2010 Altima 20K M1-105, GTX 5W30
2013 Yamaha FZ1 1K PL1410, SRT5 15W40

Top
#2461075 - 12/13/11 06:40 AM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: OVERKILL]
Merkava_4 Offline


Registered: 01/30/07
Posts: 16581
Loc: Clovis, CA
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL

You can't compare UOA's on different oils.

/Thread


Yes you can.

/OVERK1LL

crackmeup LOL

Top
#2461077 - 12/13/11 06:46 AM Re: Valvoline vs. Pennzoil Conventional (PYB) [Re: johnsmellsalot]
Hollow Offline


Registered: 02/29/08
Posts: 1311
Loc: the South
Based solely on comparing the additives used (see the most recent PQIA test results), and the fact that I have an engine that seems to prefer a higher content of Moly in the oil, I would go with PYB.

When I find a product I'm happy with, I stick with it. Most of my Subaru's life has been on SOPUS oils.


Edited by HollowEyes (12/13/11 06:47 AM)

Top
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >